Löffler H, Gassmann W, Haferlach T, Pralle H
Onkologie. 1986 Aug;9(4):196, 199-201.
In 152 patients treated with cytostatic agents for multiple myeloma the prognostic value of seven staging systems was evaluated: Carbone et al. Acute Leukemia Group B, Southeastern Cancer Study Group, Durie and Salmon, Alexanian, Merlini et al., British Medical Research Council. The staging systems of the ALGB and SECSG, both dividing patients into "good risk"- and "poor risk"-groups gave significantly different survival curves. Nevertheless, the differences were rather small. In the systems of Carbone et al., Merlini et al., Alexanian, and Durie and Salmon some of the differences in the survival curves were statistically significant while others were not. Our data best fitted into the British Medical Research Council staging system, the survival curves of all three stages showing significant differences with median survival time dropping from 83 months in stage A to 52 months in stage B and 26 months in stage C. Nevertheless, none of those systems was clearly superior to single risk factors especially creatinine and hemoglobin.
在152例接受细胞毒性药物治疗的多发性骨髓瘤患者中,评估了7种分期系统的预后价值:卡尔博内等人(急性白血病B组)、东南癌症研究组、杜里和萨尔蒙、阿列克萨尼安、梅尔利尼等人、英国医学研究委员会。急性白血病B组和东南癌症研究组的分期系统都将患者分为“低危”和“高危”组,二者给出的生存曲线有显著差异。然而,差异相当小。在卡尔博内等人、梅尔利尼等人、阿列克萨尼安以及杜里和萨尔蒙的分期系统中,生存曲线的一些差异具有统计学意义,而另一些则没有。我们的数据最符合英国医学研究委员会的分期系统,所有三个阶段的生存曲线均显示出显著差异,中位生存时间从A期的83个月降至B期的52个月和C期的26个月。然而,这些系统中没有一个明显优于单一风险因素,尤其是肌酐和血红蛋白。