C.G. Rickert was a resident in general surgery, Massachusetts General Hospital and Harvard Medical School, Boston, Massachusetts, at the time of writing and is now a transplant surgery fellow and clinical instructor, Department of Surgery, University of California, San Francisco, California.
G. Felopulos is instructor of psychology, Department of Psychiatry, Massachusetts General Hospital and Harvard Medical School, Boston, Massachusetts.
Acad Med. 2022 Oct 1;97(10):1479-1483. doi: 10.1097/ACM.0000000000004656. Epub 2022 Mar 29.
Gun violence results in approximately 40,000 deaths in the United States each year, yet physicians rarely discuss gun access and firearm safety with patients. Lack of education about how to have these conversations is an important barrier, particularly among trainees.
A 2-part training curriculum was developed for first-year residents. It included (1) a didactic presentation outlining a framework to understand types of firearm-related violence, describing institutional resources, and reviewing strategies for approaching discussions about firearms with patients, and (2) interactive case scenarios, adjusted for clinical disciplines, with standardized patients. Before and after the training, participants completed surveys on the training's relevance, efficacy, and benefit. Standardized patients provided real-time feedback to participants and completed assessments based on prespecified learning objectives.
In June-August 2019, 148 first-year residents in internal medicine (n = 74), general surgery (n = 12), emergency medicine (n = 15), pediatrics (n = 22), psychiatry (n = 16), and OB/GYN (n = 9) completed the training. Most (70%, n = 104) reported having no prior exposure to gun violence prevention education. Knowledge about available resources increased among participants from 3% (n = 5) pretraining to 97% (n = 143) post-training. Awareness about relevant laws, such as Extreme Risk Protection Orders, and their appropriate use increased from 3% (n = 4) pretraining to 98% (n = 145) post-training. Comfort discussing access to guns and gun safety with patients increased from a median of 5 pretraining to 8 post-training (on a scale of 1-10, with higher scores indicating more comfort).
Delivery of a case-based gun violence prevention training program was effective and feasible in a single institution. Next steps include expanding the training to other learners (across undergraduate and graduate medical education) and institutions and assessing how the program changes practice over time.
在美国,每年大约有 4 万人死于枪支暴力,但医生很少与患者讨论枪支的获取和枪支安全问题。缺乏关于如何进行这些对话的教育是一个重要的障碍,尤其是在受训者中。
为一年级住院医师制定了一个两部分的培训课程。它包括 (1) 一个讲座式的演示,概述了理解与枪支有关的暴力类型的框架,描述了机构资源,并审查了与患者讨论枪支的策略,以及 (2) 针对临床学科进行调整的互动案例场景,使用标准化患者。在培训前后,参与者完成了关于培训相关性、效果和益处的调查。标准化患者向参与者提供实时反馈,并根据预设的学习目标进行评估。
在 2019 年 6 月至 8 月期间,148 名内科(n = 74)、普通外科(n = 12)、急诊医学(n = 15)、儿科(n = 22)、精神病学(n = 16)和妇产科(n = 9)的一年级住院医师完成了培训。大多数人(70%,n = 104)表示以前没有接受过枪支暴力预防教育。参与者对可用资源的了解从培训前的 3%(n = 5)增加到培训后的 97%(n = 143)。参与者对相关法律的认识,如极端风险保护令及其适当使用,从培训前的 3%(n = 4)增加到培训后的 98%(n = 145)。与患者讨论获得枪支和枪支安全问题的舒适度从培训前的中位数 5 提高到培训后的 8(在 1-10 的范围内,分数越高表示越舒适)。
在单一机构中提供基于案例的枪支暴力预防培训计划是有效且可行的。下一步包括将培训扩展到其他学习者(本科和研究生医学教育)和机构,并评估该计划如何随着时间的推移改变实践。