Bergmann Melanie, Brandauer Elisabeth, Stefani Ambra, Heidbreder Anna, Unterberger Iris, Högl Birgit
Department of Neurology, Medical University of Innsbruck, Austria.
Clin Neurophysiol Pract. 2022 Feb 26;7:98-102. doi: 10.1016/j.cnp.2022.02.002. eCollection 2022.
Video-polysomnography (VPSG) and prolonged video-EEG-monitoring (pVEEG-M) are neurophysiological investigation modalities. Depending on indication either is performed, but occasionally patients undergo both (during the same or separate stays). We sought to assess the reasons and potential benefits of dual diagnostic assessments with both modalities.
A retrospective chart-review was performed to identify patients who underwent both VPSG and pVEEG-M during the 10 year period between 2007 and 2017. One-hundred-nine patients were identified who had undergone both studies. Patients were grouped according to indication and outcome.
One-hundred-nine patients had both, a VPSG and pVEEG-M, in 62 (56.9%) the studies were performed because of separate diagnoses independent from each other. In 47 patients (43.1%) investigation with both modalities was needed to clarify the suspected diagnosis or to refute differential diagnoses. Out of these 47, 11 (10.1% of the whole group) arrived a new final diagnosis whereas in 36 (33%) the primary diagnosis was corroborated with the second modality.
In the majority of cases VPSG plus pVEEG-M were indicated to diagnose or monitor different comorbid diseases (e.g. sleep-related breathing disorder and epilepsy). In the other cases, performing both modalities was useful to achieve a higher diagnostic accuracy or to refute differential diagnoses.
VPSG and pVEEG-M are neurophysiological investigations which complement each other, especially in case of two different comorbid diseases in a single patient, to rule out differential diagnosis or when a higher diagnostic certainty is seeked.
视频多导睡眠图(VPSG)和长时间视频脑电图监测(pVEEG-M)是神经生理学检查方式。根据指征进行其中一项检查,但偶尔患者会接受两项检查(在同一次或不同住院期间)。我们试图评估采用这两种方式进行双重诊断评估的原因和潜在益处。
进行回顾性病历审查,以确定在2007年至2017年这10年期间接受VPSG和pVEEG-M两项检查的患者。共识别出109例接受了这两项检查的患者。根据指征和结果对患者进行分组。
109例患者同时接受了VPSG和pVEEG-M检查,其中62例(56.9%)的两项检查是由于彼此独立的不同诊断而进行的。47例患者(43.1%)需要通过两种方式进行检查以明确疑似诊断或排除鉴别诊断。在这47例患者中,11例(占整个队列的10.1%)得出了新的最终诊断,而36例(33%)的初步诊断通过第二种方式得到了证实。
在大多数情况下,VPSG加pVEEG-M用于诊断或监测不同的合并症(如睡眠相关呼吸障碍和癫痫)。在其他情况下,同时采用两种方式有助于提高诊断准确性或排除鉴别诊断。
VPSG和pVEEG-M是相互补充的神经生理学检查,特别是在单一患者患有两种不同合并症的情况下,用于排除鉴别诊断或寻求更高的诊断确定性。