Vacheron M-N, Dugravier R, Tessier V, Deneux-Tharaux C
Psychiatrie, psychiatrie et neurosciences, GHU Paris, secteur adulte pôle 14, 75014 Paris, France.
Pédopsychiatrie, service de psychopathologie périnatale, psychiatrie et neurosciences, GHU Paris, pôle 14, 75014 Paris, France.
Encephale. 2022 Oct;48(5):590-592. doi: 10.1016/j.encep.2022.01.006. Epub 2022 Mar 21.
The sixth report of the National Confidential Survey on Maternal Deaths provides insights into the frequency, risk factors, causes, adequacy of care, and preventability of maternal deaths occurring in 2013-2015 in France. The method developed ensures an exhaustive identification and a confidential analysis of maternal deaths. It was organized in three steps. 1) All deaths occurring during pregnancy or up to 1 year after its end, whatever the cause or mode of termination, being considered 2) A pair of volunteer assessors (midwives, gyneco-obstetricians, anesthesiologists, psychiatrists) was in charge of collecting the information (history of the woman, course of her pregnancy, circumstances of the event that led to the death and management); 3) Review and classification of deaths by the National Committee of Experts on Maternal Mortality which made a collective judgment on the cause of death, on the adequacy of the care provided, and on what could been done to avoid the death depending on the existence of circumstances that could have prevented the fatal outcome. The operation of the committee has been enriched by new resources to further explore these cases. Specifically, a module of the survey questionnaire, the recruitment of psychiatrists whose contribution allows relevant documentation of the suicides, and the participation of a psychiatrist as an associate expert for the analysis of the appropriateness of the management and the variable determining factors of these cases. Suicide becomes one of the two main causes of maternal mortality, (the other cause being cardiovascular pathologies), with 35 suicides on the triennium among the 262 maternal deaths, that is to say 13.4 % of maternal deaths, about 1 per month. In this population, the average age of women who died by suicide was 31.4years. The majority of the women were born in France, 68 % were prima parous, and in 9 % of cases suicide followed a twin pregnancy. Psychiatric history was known in 33.3 % of the suicidal mothers, and 30.3 % had a history of psychiatric care that was unknown to the maternity team.43 % of the women had psychosocial vulnerability factors, a history of violence, and eviction from the home and/or financial difficulties. In 23 % of the cases, the time of occurrence of these suicides was within the first 42days postpartum, and in 77 % between 43 days and one year after birth with a median delay of 126days. Only one suicide occurred during pregnancy. Maternal suicides were mostly violent deaths. Suboptimal care was present in 72 % of cases, where 91 % of potentially preventable deaths related to a lack of multidisciplinary management and/or inadequate interaction between the patient and the health care system. Among these potentially avoidable deaths, we were able to distinguish: women whose psychiatric pathology was known and for whom multidisciplinary management was not optimal, and women whose psychiatric pathology was not known or was not present - for whom it was rather a matter of a failure to detect and identify the signs, particularly by obstetric care providers or general emergency services. Based on the analysis of the cases, strong messages were identified, with the aim of optimizing management: - The screening by structured questioning of psychiatric history from the moment of registration in the maternity ward, repeated at each consultation throughout the pregnancy. - The reassessment of the psychological and somatic state through an early postnatal interview at one month; - The identification of warning symptoms, with screening tools for depression. If necessary, a further recourse to the psychologist and/or psychiatrist of the maternity hospital, organisation of a home hospitalization, and a private midwife to provide a link in the pre- and postpartum period. This, in addition to the earliest possible care in the PMI (Maternal and Infantile Protection, of the French social care system), appointments with mental health professionals,and the link with the attending physician; - The implementation of a coordinated care pathway in case of a known psychiatric pathology with pre conception counselling. This includes a multidisciplinary collaboration, an adaptation of psychotropic treatment, management of comorbidities referral to specialized perinatal psychopathology teams, prenatal meeting with the pediatrician of the maternity hospital, anticipation of the birth, postpartum and discharge options, liaison sheet established for the organization of the delivery and postpartum, and a regular written transmissions between the intervening parties throughout the care; - The generalization of medico-psycho-social staffs, in maternity wards, for all situations identified as at risk. In addition to the need for training and increased awareness on psychological issues during the perinatal period and on the different pathologies encountered by adult mental health professionals and front-line workers, it is necessary to encourage the development of resources in the country. Particularly, joint child psychiatrist-adult psychiatrist consultations at the territorial level, responsible for being resource contacts for maternity wards and local care professionals, as well as the promotion of case pathway referrals.
法国国家孕产妇死亡保密调查报告第六版,深入剖析了2013 - 2015年间法国孕产妇死亡的频率、风险因素、原因、护理充分性及可预防性。所采用的方法确保了对孕产妇死亡进行全面识别和保密分析。该调查分为三个步骤:1)将孕期或产后一年内发生的所有死亡纳入考量,无论死因或终止妊娠的方式如何;2)由一对志愿评估人员(助产士、妇产科医生、麻醉师、精神科医生)负责收集信息(产妇病史、孕期过程、导致死亡事件的情况及处理方式);3)由国家孕产妇死亡专家委员会对死亡案例进行审查和分类,委员会就死亡原因、所提供护理的充分性以及根据是否存在可预防致命后果的情况判断如何避免死亡做出集体判断。委员会的运作因新资源的投入而得到充实,得以进一步深入研究这些案例。具体而言,调查问卷新增了一个模块,招募精神科医生参与调查,其贡献在于为自杀案例提供相关记录,并且有一名精神科医生作为副专家参与分析管理措施的合理性以及这些案例的可变决定因素。自杀成为孕产妇死亡的两大主要原因之一(另一个主要原因是心血管疾病),在262例孕产妇死亡案例中,三年间有35例自杀死亡,即占孕产妇死亡总数的13.4%,约每月1例。在这一群体中,自杀死亡女性的平均年龄为31.4岁。大多数女性出生在法国,68%为初产妇,9%的自杀案例发生在双胎妊娠之后。33.3%有自杀行为的母亲有精神病史,30.3%有精神科治疗史,但产科团队并不知晓。43%的女性存在心理社会脆弱因素、暴力史、被赶出家门和/或经济困难。23%的自杀案例发生在产后42天内,77%发生在产后43天至1年之间,中位延迟时间为126天。仅1例自杀发生在孕期。孕产妇自杀大多为暴力死亡。72%的案例存在护理欠佳的情况,其中91%的潜在可预防死亡与缺乏多学科管理和/或患者与医疗系统之间的互动不足有关。在这些潜在可避免的死亡案例中,我们能够区分出:已知存在精神疾病但多学科管理欠佳的女性,以及精神疾病未知或不存在的女性——对于后者而言,则主要是未能检测和识别相关迹象的问题,尤其是产科护理人员或普通急诊服务部门未能做到。基于对这些案例的分析,确定了一些重要建议,旨在优化管理措施:——从产妇入院登记时起,通过结构化询问筛查精神病史,并在整个孕期每次会诊时重复进行;——通过产后1个月的早期访谈重新评估心理和身体状况;——使用抑郁筛查工具识别警示症状。如有必要,进一步求助于产科医院的心理学家和/或精神科医生,安排家庭住院治疗,并聘请私人助产士在产前和产后提供衔接服务。此外,还应尽早接受母婴保护机构(法国社会护理系统)的护理、预约心理健康专业人员,并与主治医生保持联系;——对于已知存在精神疾病的情况,实施协调的护理路径并进行孕前咨询。这包括多学科协作、调整精神药物治疗、管理合并症、转诊至专业围产期精神病理学团队、与产科医院的儿科医生进行产前会诊、预期分娩、产后及出院方案、为分娩和产后护理制定联络表,以及在整个护理过程中各参与方之间定期进行书面沟通;——在产科病房,针对所有被认定为有风险的情况,推广医疗 - 心理 - 社会工作人员配置。除了需要在围产期加强关于心理问题以及成人心理健康专业人员和一线工作人员所遇到的不同病症的培训和提高认识外,还需要鼓励在国内发展相关资源。特别是建立地区层面儿童精神科医生 - 成人精神科医生联合会诊机制,负责作为产科病房和当地护理专业人员的资源联络点,并促进病例路径转诊。