School of Health & Social Care, Edinburgh Napier University, Edinburgh, United Kingdom.
Rivers Centre for Traumatic Stress, NHS Lothian, Edinburgh, United Kingdom.
Psychopathology. 2022;55(3-4):226-234. doi: 10.1159/000523825. Epub 2022 Mar 28.
The ICD-11 includes a new grouping for "disorders specifically associated with stress" that contains revised descriptions of posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) and adjustment disorder (AjD) and new diagnoses in the form of complex PTSD (CPTSD) and prolonged grief disorder (PGD). These disorders are similar in that they each require a life event for the diagnosis; however, they have not yet been assessed together for validity within the same sample. We set out to test the distinctiveness of the four main ICD-11 stress disorders using a network analysis approach.
A population-based, cross-sectional design. A nationally representative sample of adults from the Republic of Ireland aged 18 years and older (N = 1,020) completed standardized measures of PTSD, CPTSD, AjD, and PGD. A network analysis was conducted at the symptom level. Outcome measures included the International Trauma Questionnaire, the Inventory of Complicated Grief, and the International Adjustment Disorder Questionnaire.
Consistent with the taxonomic structure of the ICD-11, our results showed that although the four conditions clustered independently at the disorder level, the specific symptoms of PTSD, CPTSD, PGD, and AjD clustered together very strongly but more strongly than with symptoms of the other disorders. The majority (61%) of the variation in each symptom could be explained by its neighboring symptoms. The strongest transdiagnostically connecting symptom was "startle response."
DISCUSSION/CONCLUSION: Mental health professionals caring for people who have experienced a range of stressors and traumatic life events can be confident in diagnosing these conditions that have clear diagnostic boundaries. Interventions addressing stress-associated disorders should be based on diagnostic assessment to ensure close fit between symptoms and treatment.
ICD-11 包括一个新的“与压力特别相关的障碍”分组,其中包含对创伤后应激障碍(PTSD)和适应障碍(AjD)的修订描述,以及复杂 PTSD(CPTSD)和延长哀伤障碍(PGD)的新诊断。这些障碍的相似之处在于,它们各自的诊断都需要有生活事件;然而,它们尚未在同一样本中一起进行有效性评估。我们旨在使用网络分析方法检验 ICD-11 应激障碍的四个主要类别之间的独特性。
一项基于人群的横断面设计。爱尔兰共和国年龄在 18 岁及以上的成年人(N=1020)完成了 PTSD、CPTSD、AjD 和 PGD 的标准化测量。在症状水平上进行了网络分析。结局指标包括国际创伤问卷、复杂哀伤量表和国际适应障碍问卷。
与 ICD-11 的分类结构一致,我们的结果表明,尽管四种疾病在疾病水平上独立聚类,但 PTSD、CPTSD、PGD 和 AjD 的具体症状聚类非常紧密,但比其他疾病的症状更紧密。每个症状的大部分(61%)变化可以用其相邻症状来解释。最强的跨诊断连接症状是“惊吓反应”。
讨论/结论:照顾经历过一系列压力源和创伤性生活事件的人的心理健康专业人员,可以有信心诊断出这些具有明确诊断边界的疾病。针对与压力相关障碍的干预措施应该基于诊断评估,以确保症状和治疗之间的密切匹配。