Bonadonna G, Valagussa P, Tancini G, Rossi A, Brambilla C, Zambetti M, Bignami P, Di Fronzo G, Silvestrini R
NCI Monogr. 1986(1):45-9.
This report summarizes the most important clinical results achieved at the Milan Cancer Institute through various randomized trials with systemic adjuvant chemotherapy. In the study testing surgery versus surgery plus 12 cycles of cyclophosphamide, methotrexate, and 5-fluorouracil (CMF) in node-positive patients, the reduction in failure rate (34%) significantly favored CMF-treated patients (P less than 0.001). Despite a reduction in the death rate of 23%, the overall survival showed only a trend for CMF compared to surgery alone (P = 0.10). In a second study, the 8-year results confirmed the lack of difference in relapse-free survival and total survival rates between patients who received 12 and 6 cycles of CMF. The third study indicated that at 6 years, postmenopausal women who had 1-3 positive lymph nodes and were treated with full-dose sequential non-cross-resistant combinations had rates of relapse-free survival and total survival that were superior to those previously achieved with CMF in the same menopausal subset. In a limited series of patients with negative axillary nodes as well as negative estrogen receptors, there was clear evidence of very poor prognosis in women given only local-regional therapy, compared to women treated with adjuvant CMF. Within the node-negative subset, the proliferative activity (labeling index) of the primary tumor appears to be a more effective prognostic discriminant than estrogen receptor status. The proportion of primary drug-resistant tumor cells as well as the lack of relative dose intensity in the drug programs tested so far probably represent the two most important causes for the failure of adjuvant chemotherapy.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)
本报告总结了米兰癌症研究所在多项系统性辅助化疗随机试验中取得的最重要临床结果。在一项针对淋巴结阳性患者的研究中,比较了手术与手术加12周期环磷酰胺、甲氨蝶呤和5-氟尿嘧啶(CMF)的疗效,结果显示失败率降低了34%,这显著有利于接受CMF治疗的患者(P小于0.001)。尽管死亡率降低了23%,但与单纯手术相比,CMF治疗组的总生存率仅呈趋势性提高(P = 0.10)。在第二项研究中,8年的结果证实,接受12周期和6周期CMF治疗的患者在无复发生存率和总生存率方面没有差异。第三项研究表明,在6年时,有1 - 3个阳性淋巴结的绝经后女性接受全剂量序贯非交叉耐药联合治疗,其无复发生存率和总生存率优于之前在相同绝经亚组中使用CMF所取得的结果。在一系列腋窝淋巴结阴性且雌激素受体阴性的有限患者中,与接受辅助CMF治疗的女性相比,仅接受局部区域治疗的女性预后明显很差。在淋巴结阴性亚组中,原发肿瘤的增殖活性(标记指数)似乎比雌激素受体状态更能有效区分预后。到目前为止,所测试的药物方案中原发耐药肿瘤细胞的比例以及相对剂量强度的不足可能是辅助化疗失败的两个最重要原因。(摘要截选至250词)