Pereira Nicola M, Kacker Ashutosh
Department of Otolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery, Weill Cornell Medicine, New York, New York, USA.
OTO Open. 2022 Mar 28;6(1):2473974X221088282. doi: 10.1177/2473974X221088282. eCollection 2022 Jan-Mar.
This study aims to characterize the top-ranked departments in otolaryngology to provide an indicator of the state of diversity within otolaryngology and to draw a comparison with other medical and surgical fields.
This cross-sectional study examined the 20 highest-ranked otolaryngology programs according to the ranking of best hospitals for ear, nose and throat.
Academic otolaryngology departments in the United States.
Faculty demographic and biographical data were collected from departmental websites. The Web of Science -index was used as a surrogate for academic productivity. Descriptive statistics and chi-square analysis were used to characterize the cohort and compare otolaryngology with other fields.
Of 562 otolaryngologists on faculty at the 20 highest-ranked programs, 413 (73.5%) were men and 149 (26.5%) were women. Among the faculty in the cohort, 174 (31.0%) were professors, 145 (25.8%) were associate professors, and 183 (32.6%) were assistant professors. Across faculty appointments, the proportion of women grew smaller as academic rank increased. When compared with all faculty across US medical schools, the departments in this study had significantly lower proportions of female professors ( = .0047), associate professors ( = .0009), and assistant professors ( = .0005). Male faculty members had higher -indices than their female counterparts among professors ( = .004), associate professors ( = .008), assistant professors ( = .0002), and clinical assistant professors ( = .0009).
Women are underrepresented across all academic ranks in top-ranked otolaryngology programs. The current state of diversity in otolaryngology yields many opportunities to advance representation for women in the field.
本研究旨在对排名靠前的耳鼻喉科科室进行特征分析,以提供耳鼻喉科领域多样性状况的指标,并与其他医学和外科领域进行比较。
本横断面研究根据耳鼻喉科最佳医院排名,对排名前20的耳鼻喉科项目进行了考察。
美国的学术性耳鼻喉科科室。
从科室网站收集教职员工的人口统计学和个人传记数据。使用科学引文索引作为学术产出的替代指标。描述性统计和卡方分析用于描述该队列特征,并将耳鼻喉科与其他领域进行比较。
在排名前20的项目中,562名教职员工耳鼻喉科医生中,413名(73.5%)为男性,149名(26.5%)为女性。在该队列的教职员工中,174名(31.0%)为教授,145名(25.8%)为副教授,183名(32.6%)为助理教授。在所有教职员工任命中,随着学术职级的提高,女性比例逐渐降低。与美国所有医学院的全体教职员工相比,本研究中的科室女性教授比例(= .0047)、副教授比例(= .0009)和助理教授比例(= .0005)显著更低。在教授(= .004)、副教授(= .008)、助理教授(= .0002)和临床助理教授(= .0009)中,男性教职员工的索引高于女性同行。
在排名靠前的耳鼻喉科项目中,女性在所有学术职级中的代表性不足。耳鼻喉科目前的多样性状况为提高该领域女性的代表性提供了许多机会。