Gastroenterology, The Affiliated Hospital of Southwest Medical University, China.
Gastroenterology, The People's Hospital of Lianshui, China.
Rev Esp Enferm Dig. 2022 Sep;114(9):566-567. doi: 10.17235/reed.2022.8817/2022.
Review of retracted articles has a positive impact on scientific research. The aim of our study was to examine the characteristics of retracted articles in the field of pancreatic diseases.
The Retraction Watch database was queried for retractions in pancreatic diseases on 7 March 2021, and the filters set were as follows: (1) the Title typed in was "pancreatitis", "pancreas", or "pancreatic"; (2) the Nature of notice selected was "retraction".
A total of 116 retracted articles were identified as pancreatic disease-related, with over two-thirds of them pertaining to pancreatic cancer. Research article was the most common article type among these retractions. Common reasons given for retraction included scientific fraud (37.1%), duplication (26.7%), and reliability (25%). China had the largest number of retractions (n=51), followed by the United States (n=47). Most articles were retracted in recent years, particularly after 2015.
A large proportion of retracted articles pertaining to pancreatic diseases have been retracted in recent years. The majority of publications-over three quarters-were retracted for authors who committed some type of misconduct. Differences between countries in the manner of misconduct were stark.
对已撤回文章的审查对科学研究有积极影响。我们的研究目的是研究胰腺疾病领域已撤回文章的特征。
于 2021 年 3 月 7 日在 Retraction Watch 数据库中检索胰腺疾病相关的撤回文章,并设置如下筛选条件:(1)标题中输入“胰腺炎”、“胰腺”或“胰脏”;(2)选择的通知性质为“撤回”。
共确定 116 篇与胰腺疾病相关的已撤回文章,其中超过三分之二与胰腺癌有关。在这些撤回文章中,研究文章是最常见的文章类型。撤回的常见原因包括科学欺诈(37.1%)、重复(26.7%)和可靠性问题(25%)。中国的撤回数量最多(n=51),其次是美国(n=47)。大多数文章是在近几年撤回的,尤其是在 2015 年之后。
近年来,大量与胰腺疾病相关的已撤回文章被撤回。大多数出版物——超过四分之三——都是因作者犯有某种类型的不当行为而撤回的。各国在不当行为方式上存在明显差异。