Senior Fellow, BIDMC Disaster Medicine Fellowship, Department of Emergency Medicine, Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center and Harvard Medical School, Boston, Massachusetts, USA.
Director, BIDMC Disaster Medicine Fellowship, Department of Emergency Medicine, Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center; Associate Professor, Harvard Medical School, Boston, Massachusetts, USA.
Prehosp Disaster Med. 2022 Jun;37(3):327-332. doi: 10.1017/S1049023X22000528. Epub 2022 Apr 8.
The use of chemical weapons in terrorist attacks, though rare, remains a significant challenge and concern due to their ability to inflict mass casualties. Chemical attacks remain a topic of interest for Disaster Medicine (DM) and Counter-Terrorism Medicine (CTM) specialists and are clearly an area in need of enhanced preparedness. This study aims to provide an epidemiological description of all terrorism-related attacks using chemical agents as a primary weapon, sustained from 1970 - 2019. These data will be useful in the development of education programs in CTM and provide an insight into how best to prepare for potential attacks in the future.
Data collection was performed using a retrospective database search through the Global Terrorism Database (GTD). The GTD was searched using the internal database search functions for all events using chemical weapons as a primary attack method from January 1, 1970 - December 31, 2019. Years 2020 and 2021 were not yet available at the time of the study. The GTD also details the specific chemical used, when known, in the summary of incidents. Results were exported into an Excel spreadsheet (Microsoft Corp.; Redmond, Washington USA) for analysis.
A total of 292 terrorist attacks involving chemical agents as a primary attack method were recorded from 1970 - 2019, registering 284 deaths and 13,267 injuries. Acid (52) was the most commonly used chemical agent, followed by "unspecified poison" (43), "unknown chemical agents" (29), "unspecified gas" (27), tear gas (27), chlorine gas (24), cyanide (21), mercury (9), pepper spray or mace (9), mustard gas (8), insecticide or 1080 (8), diphenylamine chloroarsine (7), phosphate or phosphorous (3), sodium hydroxide or corrosive liquid (3), sarin (2), "unspecified drugs" (2), VX nerve gas and other nerve gas (2), pesticides (2), cleaning chemicals/paint thinner (2), ammonia (2), anesthesia agent (1), arsenic (1), chlorine and mustard gas mix (1), phenarsazine chloride (1), rat poison (1), unknown irritative gas (1), hydrochloric acid and sodium cyanide mix (1), unknown white powder (1), antiseptic dye (1), and chlorine gas and white phosphorous mix (1).
The use of chemical weapons in warfare, though prohibited by the Chemical Weapons Convention (CWC), remains a rare but concerning terrorist attack methodology. In recent years, there have been more instances where potentially deadly chemicals have been used in civilian settings. Dual use industrial chemicals, in particular, pose a significant concern. Acid was the most commonly used chemical weapon in 52 attacks. Tear gas, chlorine, and cyanide were each used in over 20 attacks. Both DM and CTM specialists advocate for better preparedness and response training for intentional events in civilian settings.
尽管恐怖袭击中使用化学武器的情况很少见,但由于其造成大规模伤亡的能力,这仍然是一个重大挑战和关注点。化学袭击仍然是灾难医学(DM)和反恐医学(CTM)专家关注的话题,显然是一个需要加强准备的领域。本研究旨在提供 1970 年至 2019 年间所有以化学制剂为主要武器的恐怖袭击相关事件的流行病学描述。这些数据将有助于 CTM 教育项目的开发,并深入了解如何最好地为未来的潜在袭击做好准备。
通过全球恐怖主义数据库(GTD)进行回顾性数据库检索来进行数据收集。使用 GTD 的内部数据库搜索功能,搜索了 1970 年 1 月 1 日至 2019 年 12 月 31 日期间所有使用化学武器作为主要攻击手段的事件。在研究时,2020 年和 2021 年的数据尚未可用。GTD 还详细说明了在事件摘要中已知的特定化学制剂。结果被导出到 Excel 电子表格(美国华盛顿州雷德蒙德的微软公司)中进行分析。
1970 年至 2019 年期间共记录了 292 起涉及化学制剂作为主要攻击手段的恐怖袭击事件,造成 284 人死亡,13267 人受伤。酸(52 起)是最常用的化学制剂,其次是“未指定毒药”(43 起)、“不明化学制剂”(29 起)、“未指定气体”(27 起)、催泪瓦斯(27 起)、氯气(24 起)、氰化物(21 起)、汞(9 起)、胡椒喷雾或防暴喷雾(9 起)、芥子气(8 起)、杀虫剂或 1080(8 起)、二苯氨基氯胂(7 起)、磷酸盐或磷(3 起)、氢氧化钠或腐蚀性液体(3 起)、沙林(2 起)、“未指定药物”(2 起)、VX 神经毒气和其他神经毒气(2 起)、杀虫剂(2 起)、清洁化学品/油漆稀释剂(2 起)、氨(2 起)、麻醉剂(1 起)、砷(1 起)、氯气和芥子气混合物(1 起)、苯偶氮苯胂氯(1 起)、老鼠药(1 起)、不明刺激性气体(1 起)、盐酸和氰化钠混合物(1 起)、不明白色粉末(1 起)、防腐剂染料(1 起)、氯气和白磷混合物(1 起)。
尽管《化学武器公约》(CWC)禁止在战争中使用化学武器,但化学武器作为一种罕见但令人关切的恐怖袭击手段仍然存在。近年来,在民用环境中使用潜在致命化学品的情况有所增加。特别是两用工业化学品构成了重大关切。在 52 起袭击中使用了酸。催泪瓦斯、氯气和氰化物都在 20 多起袭击中使用过。DM 和 CTM 专家都主张加强对民用环境中蓄意事件的准备和应对培训。