Department of Psychology, University of Liverpool, Liverpool, UK.
Division of Medical Education, University of Manchester, Manchester, UK.
Obes Rev. 2022 Aug;23(8):e13451. doi: 10.1111/obr.13451. Epub 2022 Apr 10.
Interactions about children's weight and weight-related behaviors occur from an early stage in school settings between various stakeholders and are often intended to facilitate weight-related behavioral change in children and/or families. This meta-synthesis (PROSPERO - CRD42019133231) aimed to investigate stakeholder reported experiences and challenges of these encounters. Studies were eligible if they included school stakeholders (teaching or nonteaching staff, parents, caregivers, or children), explored communication topics related to child obesity (weight, diet or activity), were conducted within an early school setting (primary school stage or international equivalent), and used qualitative methods. Database searches conducted March-July 2019 (updated November 2020) identified 40 studies (2324 participants) from seven countries. Included studies were assessed for quality using the Critical Appraisal Skills Programme. Using inductive thematic analysis, we identified four core themes across this database: (1) "conversation characteristics and consequences," (2) "missing components," (3) "avoiding stigma," and (4) "school responsibilities." Overall, stakeholders recognized that schools are well-positioned to provide positive influential messages about childhood obesity and reported that discussions on this topic do occur in early school settings but that stakeholders find them difficult, complex, and lack the necessary skills to deliver the nonjudgmental, consistent, and tailored support that they desire.
在学校环境中,各种利益相关者很早就开始就儿童的体重和与体重相关的行为进行互动,其目的通常是促进儿童和/或家庭的与体重相关的行为改变。这项荟萃分析(PROSPERO - CRD42019133231)旨在调查利益相关者报告的这些互动的经验和挑战。如果研究包括学校利益相关者(教学或非教学人员、家长、照顾者或儿童),探讨与儿童肥胖相关的沟通主题(体重、饮食或活动),在早期学校环境(小学阶段或国际同等水平)内进行,并且使用定性方法,则研究合格。2019 年 3 月至 7 月(2020 年 11 月更新)进行了数据库搜索,确定了来自七个国家的 40 项研究(2324 名参与者)。使用批判性评估技能计划对纳入的研究进行了质量评估。使用归纳主题分析,我们在整个数据库中确定了四个核心主题:(1)“对话特征和后果”,(2)“缺失的组件”,(3)“避免污名化”和(4)“学校责任”。总体而言,利益相关者认识到学校非常适合提供有关儿童肥胖的积极影响信息,并报告说在早期学校环境中确实会讨论这个话题,但利益相关者发现这些话题很难、很复杂,并且缺乏必要的技能来提供他们所期望的非评判性、一致性和量身定制的支持。