Gailits Nicola, Pastor-Bravo M M, Gastaldo D, Bajwa U, Bilbao-Joseph C, Castro C, Godoy S
Dalla Lana School of Public Health, University of Toronto, Toronto, Canada.
Global Migration & Health Initiative, University of Toronto, Toronto, Canada.
Int J Transgend Health. 2021 Nov 4;23(1-2):5-23. doi: 10.1080/26895269.2021.1988877. eCollection 2022.
Worldwide, Trans women from Latin America experience some of the highest rates of violence, which has led many to emigrate. There is limited research exploring the experiences of Trans migrants, and most LGBTQI2S + migrant research focuses on immigrant gay men. This study uses the frameworks of Intersectionality and the Social Determinants of Health (SDoH) to examine the impact of migration on the health and wellbeing of Latin American Trans women living in Toronto, Canada.
This qualitative arts-based study included nine participants and used hand mapping, a sociodemographic questionnaire, and focus groups to generate data. Data analysis encompassed inductive and deductive approaches and rigor was maintained through reflexivity and several verification strategies.
While migration was used as a safety strategy, participants' multiple identities as immigrants, Trans women, and Latinas, produced compounded experiences of oppression post-migration. Facing transphobia and xenophobia simultaneously, participants were forced to navigate precarious housing and employment, minimal social capital, and low social position. This limited their ability to exercise power and ultimately caused poor health and wellbeing post-migration; however, participants used sophisticated strategies to resist asymmetrical power relations, actively searching for safety and community participation, and caring for themselves and each other.
The participants fought for inclusion across borders of economic exclusion and gender identity, borders of power and social position, as well as geopolitical borders. Their intersectional experiences across these "borders" should be understood in the context of migration without liberation, consumption without income, compounding oppressions, as well as positive intersectionality. While the women's resistance and strength are positive by-products of fighting oppression, they cannot be the solution. Access to health and wellbeing should not be a privilege for some; it must be a right for all.
在全球范围内,来自拉丁美洲的跨性别女性遭受着一些最高的暴力发生率,这导致许多人移民。探索跨性别移民经历的研究有限,而且大多数 LGBTQI2S+ 移民研究都集中在移民男同性恋者身上。本研究使用交叉性理论和健康的社会决定因素框架,来考察移民对居住在加拿大多伦多的拉丁美洲跨性别女性的健康和福祉的影响。
这项基于艺术的定性研究包括九名参与者,并使用手绘地图、社会人口统计问卷和焦点小组来收集数据。数据分析采用归纳法和演绎法,并通过反思和多种验证策略来确保严谨性。
虽然移民被用作一种安全策略,但参与者作为移民、跨性别女性和拉丁裔的多重身份,在移民后产生了叠加的压迫经历。同时面临恐跨症和仇外心理,参与者被迫应对不稳定的住房和就业、极少的社会资本以及较低的社会地位。这限制了她们行使权力的能力,最终导致移民后的健康和福祉不佳;然而,参与者使用复杂的策略来抵制不对称的权力关系,积极寻求安全和社区参与,并相互照顾。
参与者跨越经济排斥和性别认同的边界、权力和社会地位的边界以及地缘政治边界争取包容。她们在这些“边界”上的交叉经历应在没有解放的移民、没有收入的消费、叠加的压迫以及积极的交叉性背景下得到理解。虽然女性的抵抗和力量是与压迫作斗争的积极副产品,但它们不是解决办法。获得健康和福祉不应是某些人的特权;它必须是所有人的权利。