Center for Human Genetics, Faculty of Medicine, KU Leuven, Leuven, Belgium.
Center for Human Genetics, Faculty of Medicine, University of Kinshasa, Kinshasa, Democratic Republic of Congo.
J Clin Lab Anal. 2022 May;36(5):e24398. doi: 10.1002/jcla.24398. Epub 2022 Apr 11.
Hemoglobin-based tests form the reference diagnostic test for SCA. In limited resource countries, these tests face limitations including cost, low sensitivity due to recurrent transfusions in endemic malaria region, and interference from fetal hemoglobin in neonatal diagnostic. This study aimed at adapting DNA-based SCA tests to limited resource countries and evaluating the economic benefit.
338 participants were recruited in the Democratic Republic of Congo, sorted in 3 cohorts based on venous blood, umbilical cord blood (UCB) and buccal swab sampling. RFLP was performed to identify mutated allele. The feasibility and technical validity of this RFLP was evaluated for specimens collected on DBS cards and on EDTA tubes. RFLP on DBS stored at room temperature was regularly repeated to assess sample conservation. Finally, the cost analysis was performed.
DBS cards yielded identical results to extracted DNA. Repeated testing returned the same result after four years. The DBS-based test performed on UCB or on buccal swab had a sensitivity and a precision of 100%. Cost comparison indicated that our approach costs half price of the widely used isoelectrofocussing of hemoglobin.
The implemented DNA-based test approach overcomes the limitations faced by hemoglobin-based tests, while being more affordable. We propose to implement the RFLP test as a first line diagnostic test after transfusion and as second tiers for newborn screening. However, users should be aware that this test is unable to differentiate HbC from HbS or identify other point mutation of gene deletion of HBB gene.
基于血红蛋白的检测是镰状细胞病的参考诊断检测。在资源有限的国家,这些检测方法存在一些局限性,包括成本高、由于地方性疟疾地区反复输血导致敏感性低,以及在新生儿诊断中受到胎儿血红蛋白的干扰。本研究旨在将基于 DNA 的 SCA 检测方法应用于资源有限的国家,并评估其经济效益。
在刚果民主共和国招募了 338 名参与者,根据静脉血、脐带血(UCB)和口腔拭子采样将参与者分为 3 组。采用 RFLP 鉴定突变等位基因。评估了 DBS 卡和 EDTA 管上采集的标本的 RFLP 可行性和技术有效性。定期重复 DBS 上的 RFLP 以评估样本保存情况。最后,进行了成本分析。
DBS 卡与提取的 DNA 产生相同的结果。经过四年的重复测试,结果仍然相同。基于 DBS 的 UCB 或口腔拭子检测具有 100%的灵敏度和精确度。成本比较表明,我们的方法比广泛使用的血红蛋白等电聚焦法便宜一半。
所实施的基于 DNA 的检测方法克服了基于血红蛋白的检测方法所面临的局限性,同时更具成本效益。我们建议在输血后将 RFLP 检测作为一线诊断检测,并作为新生儿筛查的二线检测。然而,用户应该注意,该检测无法区分 HbC 和 HbS,也无法识别 HBB 基因突变的其他点突变或缺失。