Hibbard R A, Roghmann K, Hoekelman R A
Pediatrics. 1987 Jan;79(1):129-37.
Many sexual abuse victims have been observed to draw genitalia on human figures. To test the hypothesis that sexually abused children draw genitalia on human figures more often than do nonabused children, drawings from 57 children, 3 through 7 years of age, who were referred to child protective services as alleged sexual abuse victims, were compared with drawings from an age-, sex-, race-, and socioeconomically matched group of 55 nonabused children receiving well-child care in medical settings. A standardized procedure to obtain drawings was followed by a structured interview to collect demographic, past medical, and developmental information. Five evaluators unaware of the children's backgrounds independently examined drawings for the presence or absence of five body parts; there was 94% agreement for all body parts and 93% agreement for genitalia. Eight children were excluded from the analysis because they only scribbled (n = 5) or because evaluators could not agree on whether genitalia were present in their drawings (n = 3). Ten percent (5/52) of the alleged sexual abuse victims and 2% (1/52) of the comparison children drew genitalia (P = .10, one-tailed Fisher exact test). The estimated relative risk was 5.4; that is, alleged sexual abuse victims were 5.4 times more likely to draw genitalia than were comparison children. Children known to have been sexually abused were 6.8 times more likely to draw genitalia than were comparison children (P = .07, one-tailed Fisher exact test).(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)
许多性虐待受害者被观察到会在人物画像上画出生殖器。为了检验性虐待儿童比未受虐待儿童更频繁地在人物画像上画出生殖器这一假设,将57名3至7岁被转介至儿童保护服务机构的所谓性虐待受害者儿童的画作,与55名在医疗机构接受健康儿童护理的年龄、性别、种族和社会经济状况相匹配的未受虐待儿童的画作进行了比较。在遵循标准化程序获取画作后,通过结构化访谈收集人口统计学、既往病史和发育信息。五名不了解儿童背景的评估人员独立检查画作中五个身体部位的有无;所有身体部位的一致性为94%,生殖器部位的一致性为93%。八名儿童被排除在分析之外,因为他们只是随意涂鸦(n = 5),或者因为评估人员对他们的画作中是否存在生殖器无法达成一致(n = 3)。10%(5/52)的所谓性虐待受害者儿童和2%(1/52)的对照儿童画出了生殖器(P = .10,单尾费舍尔精确检验)。估计相对风险为5.4;也就是说,所谓性虐待受害者儿童画出生殖器的可能性是对照儿童的5.4倍。已知遭受性虐待的儿童画出生殖器的可能性是对照儿童的6.8倍(P = .07,单尾费舍尔精确检验)。(摘要截断于250字)