University of Utah School of Medicine, Center for Global Surgery, 30 N. 1900 E RM 3B110 SOM, Salt Lake City, UT 84132, USA.
J Pediatr Urol. 2022 Jun;18(3):271-279. doi: 10.1016/j.jpurol.2022.02.002. Epub 2022 Feb 17.
Over the course of approximately 60 years, the field of pediatric urology has evolved as a convergence of pediatric surgery, urology, and plastic surgery to address congenital anomalies of the urinary tract and genitalia in children. Guidelines for training and certification are narrowing in high-income countries (HICs) at the same time as the fertility rate is declining and the prevalence of complex genitourinary (GU) conditions is decreasing. In low-and middle-income countries (LMICs), health systems for large populations are currently in a state of stress. Here we briefly review the history of pediatric urology as a surgical subspecialty, identify unmet needs especially in LMICs and place the field in the context of a global surgical ecosystem.
The English language literature on workforce trends in pediatric urology, pediatric surgery and urology was reviewed as well as development of the emerging field of global surgery. Global surgery looks at the social, economic and political context of health systems as well as unmet clinical need. World trends in fertility rates were reviewed to identify regions of workforce surplus and gaps, supply chain needs, infrastructure and systems strengths and weaknesses.
The proliferation of training programs in pediatric surgery and specialties in high-income countries (HICs) coupled with declining birth rates has led to a saturation of specialists and declining surgical case load. In LMICs, while the birth rate has also been declining, surgical specialization has not progressed. In the lowest income countries, especially in sub-Saharan Africa, training in pediatric surgical specialties and urology is rare. The broad workforce that supports surgical care, such as anesthesia, intensivist pediatrics, radiology, laboratory, and nursing face similar challenges. Supply chains for specialized pediatric urological surgery are weak.
There is an evolving maldistribution of pediatric surgical and pediatric urological workforce globally, with too few practitioners in LMICs and too many in HICs. The high cost of specialized equipment limits access to quality care, and the supply chain for consumables and medication is patchy. In LIC's, basic community-based infrastructure for health including reliable electricity is lacking. Recent experience with Covid and environmental disasters has highlighted that even in HICs surgical resilience can be challenged. This is an opportunity to consider the state of children's urological care globally and to build resilience by identifying and addressing strengths and gaps.
本研究旨在简要回顾小儿外科学作为外科亚专科的发展历程,明确高收入国家(HICs)和低收入及中等收入国家(LMICs)未满足的需求,并将该领域置于全球外科生态系统的背景下进行探讨。
我们对小儿外科学、小儿外科和泌尿外科领域劳动力趋势的英文文献进行了回顾,并对新兴全球外科学领域的发展进行了研究。全球外科学着眼于卫生系统的社会、经济和政治背景以及未满足的临床需求。我们回顾了全球生育率趋势,以确定劳动力过剩和短缺地区、供应链需求、基础设施和系统的优势和劣势。
HICs 中小儿外科学和专科培训项目的激增,加上出生率的下降,导致专家饱和,手术病例量下降。在 LMICs,尽管出生率也在下降,但外科专业化并未取得进展。在收入最低的国家,特别是撒哈拉以南非洲国家,小儿外科学和泌尿外科的专科培训非常罕见。支持外科护理的广泛劳动力,如麻醉、儿科重症监护、放射科、实验室和护理人员,也面临着类似的挑战。专门的小儿泌尿外科手术供应链薄弱。
全球小儿外科学和小儿泌尿外科劳动力的分布不均衡,LMICs 的从业人员太少,而 HICs 的则太多。专门设备的高成本限制了获得高质量护理的机会,消耗品和药物的供应链也不完善。在LICs,包括可靠电力在内的基本社区卫生基础设施也缺乏。最近在 HICs 发生的新冠疫情和环境灾害突显了即使在 HICs,外科手术的恢复能力也可能受到挑战。这是一个机会,可以考虑全球儿童泌尿科护理的状况,并通过确定和解决优势和差距来建立弹性。