Mofidi Amirsalar, Perez Arnaldo, Kornerup Ida, Levin Liran, Ortiz Silvia, Lai Hollis, Green Jacqueline, Kim Seongju, Gibson Monica P
Faculty of Medicine and Dentistry, School of Dentistry, University of Alberta, Edmonton, AB T6G 1C9, Canada.
Dent J (Basel). 2022 Apr 6;10(4):63. doi: 10.3390/dj10040063.
Evidence on periodontal education areas in which students have difficulties and their factors are limited. In this study, third- and fourth-year dental students' knowledge was assessed as well as their confidence and ability in five periodontal educational areas using a mixed-method approach. A survey was used to collect data related to history-taking, medical examination, diagnosis, treatment planning, and follow-up. Student answers were compared to the consensual answers of an expert panel using the cosine-similarity index (CSI). Descriptive statistics assessed confidence and ability for diagnosis. Semi-structured individual interviews were used to collect data on reported reasons for difficulties in periodontal education. A content analysis was employed to analyze the interview data. Eighteen third- and fourth-year dental students completed the survey and eleven were interviewed. Students' knowledge was adequate regarding diagnosis and treatment planning. Third-year students' median CSI were 0.93 and 0.89, respectively. Fourth-year students' median CSI were 0.9 and 0.93, respectively. Students felt confident in history-taking and examination but lacked confidence and ability in diagnosis and treatment planning. Reported reasons for difficulties in periodontal education were linked to both preclinical and clinical pedagogical issues. Further improvements in preclinical and clinical periodontal education are needed to address students' lack of knowledge, confidence, and skills in key periodontal areas.
关于学生在牙周教育领域存在困难及其相关因素的证据有限。在本研究中,采用混合方法评估了牙科三、四年级学生在五个牙周教育领域的知识、信心和能力。通过一项调查收集了与病史采集、体格检查、诊断、治疗计划和随访相关的数据。使用余弦相似度指数(CSI)将学生的答案与专家小组的一致答案进行比较。描述性统计评估了诊断的信心和能力。采用半结构化个人访谈收集有关牙周教育中报告的困难原因的数据。运用内容分析法对访谈数据进行分析。18名牙科三、四年级学生完成了调查,11名学生接受了访谈。学生在诊断和治疗计划方面的知识足够。三年级学生的CSI中位数分别为0.93和0.89。四年级学生的CSI中位数分别为0.9和0.93。学生在病史采集和检查方面有信心,但在诊断和治疗计划方面缺乏信心和能力。报告的牙周教育困难原因与临床前和临床教学问题都有关。需要进一步改进临床前和临床牙周教育,以解决学生在关键牙周领域知识、信心和技能不足的问题。