Dev World Bioeth. 2023 Jun;23(2):166-175. doi: 10.1111/dewb.12352. Epub 2022 Apr 25.
The Oceania region is home to some of the world's most restrictive abortion laws, and there is evidence of Pacific Island women's reproductive oppression across several aspects of their reproductive lives, including in relation to contraceptive decision-making, birthing, and fertility. In this paper we analyse documents from court cases in the Pacific Islands regarding the illegal procurement of abortion. We undertook inductive thematic analysis of documents from eighteen illegal abortion court cases from Pacific Island countries. Using the lens of reproductive justice, we discuss the methods of abortion, the reported context of these abortions, and the ways in which these women and abortion were constructed in judges' summing up, judgements, or sentencing. Our analysis of these cases reveals layers of sexual and reproductive oppression experienced by these women that are related to colonialism, women's socioeconomic disadvantage, gendered violence, limited reproductive control, and the punitive consequences related to not performing gender appropriately.
大洋洲地区拥有一些世界上最严格的堕胎法,有证据表明,太平洋岛屿妇女在其生殖生活的多个方面受到生殖压迫,包括在避孕决策、分娩和生育能力方面。在本文中,我们分析了太平洋岛屿国家法院关于非法堕胎的案件文件。我们对来自太平洋岛国 18 起非法堕胎案件的文件进行了归纳主题分析。我们使用生殖正义的视角,讨论了堕胎的方法、这些堕胎的报告背景,以及法官在总结、判决或判刑中对这些妇女和堕胎的描述方式。我们对这些案件的分析揭示了这些妇女所经历的多层性和生殖压迫,这些压迫与殖民主义、妇女的社会经济劣势、性别暴力、有限的生殖控制以及与性别不适当相关的惩罚后果有关。