Department of Interventional Radiology, Yale School of Medicine, New Haven, Connecticut.
Department of Interventional Radiology, Yale School of Medicine, New Haven, Connecticut.
J Vasc Interv Radiol. 2022 Aug;33(8):993-1000. doi: 10.1016/j.jvir.2022.04.010. Epub 2022 Apr 22.
This study aimed to review systematically the efficacy, safety, and technical aspects of cryoablation in the treatment of venous malformations (VMs) and to provide the groundwork for future studies. A literature search for clinical studies utilizing percutaneous cryoablation of VMs was performed. All clinical studies related to primary or secondary treatment of VMs with percutaneous cryoablation were included in this review. These selected studies were evaluated for patient characteristics, cryoablation technique, technical success, lesion size and pain scores before and after cryoablation, and adverse outcomes. Random effects analysis of postprocedural changes in lesion volume and pain scores was performed. There were 54 patients with 55 cases of cryoablation of VMs. Of these cases, 27 recorded changes in lesion volume and 31 recorded changes in pain scores. The weighted mean postprocedural decrease in lesion size was 92.0% (raw average, 71.7%). The weighted mean reduction in pain score was 77% (raw average, 78.2%). Considering all treated cases (55), complete resolution of symptoms was seen in 35 cases (63.6%) and overall (complete or partial) improvement in 52 cases (94.5%). Common postprocedural symptoms included pain, bruising, swelling and numbness lasting less than 2 weeks. There were two major adverse events (3.7%), with both cases due to persistent dysesthesia. Patients with a history of prior sclerotherapy demonstrated lower preprocedural and postprocedural pain scores (4.7 and 1.3) than patients without prior treatments (5.8 and 2.8). Cryoablation of VMs appears to be potentially safe and effective on limited short-interval follow-up.
本研究旨在系统性地回顾冷冻消融治疗静脉畸形(VM)的疗效、安全性和技术方面,并为未来的研究提供基础。对采用经皮冷冻消融治疗 VM 的临床研究进行了文献检索。本综述纳入了所有与经皮冷冻消融治疗原发性或继发性 VM 的相关临床研究。对患者特征、冷冻消融技术、技术成功率、冷冻消融前后病变大小和疼痛评分以及不良结局进行了评估。对病变体积和疼痛评分的术后变化进行了随机效应分析。共纳入 54 例 55 个 VM 冷冻消融病例,其中 27 例记录了病变体积的变化,31 例记录了疼痛评分的变化。术后病变大小的平均降低率为 92.0%(原始平均值为 71.7%),疼痛评分的平均降低率为 77%(原始平均值为 78.2%)。考虑所有治疗病例(55 例),35 例(63.6%)症状完全缓解,52 例(94.5%)总体(完全或部分)改善。常见的术后症状包括疼痛、瘀斑、肿胀和麻木,持续时间少于 2 周。有 2 例严重不良事件(3.7%),均因持续感觉异常所致。有既往硬化治疗史的患者术前和术后疼痛评分(4.7 和 1.3)均低于无既往治疗史的患者(5.8 和 2.8)。在有限的短期随访中,冷冻消融治疗 VM 似乎是安全有效的。