Herzberg Guillaume, Burnier Marion, Druel Thibault
Department of Orthopedics, TRues Wrist Surgery Unit, Clinique Parc Lyon, Lyon, France.
Department of Orthopedics, TRues Wrist Surgery Unit, Institut Main Membre Supérieur, Villeurbanne, France.
J Wrist Surg. 2021 Nov 15;11(2):161-163. doi: 10.1055/s-0041-1736607. eCollection 2022 Apr.
Reverse perilunate injuries (REPLI) are rare variants of the classic radial-sided perilunate injuries (PLI) whose mechanism was described by Mayfield in 1980. Classic radial-sided nontranscaphoid dorsal PLI invariably display a flexed, foreshortened position of the scaphoid on their initial posteroanterior (PA) and lateral radiographs. We observed that some dorsal perilunate dislocations displayed an position of the scaphoid on their initial radiographs. Our hypothesis is that this extended position of the scaphoid was associated with a REPLI pattern. The PA and lateral initial emergency radiographs of our specialized wrist surgery series of 114 dorsal pure ligamentous PLI (within a 186 cases series of PLI treated between 2004 and 2020) were reviewed as well as the available figures of the current REPLI literature. A total of seven cases of cases within our dorsal PLI series displayed an extended position of the scaphoid on their initial PA and lateral radiographs, while 107 cases displayed a flexed, foreshortened position. The PA and lateral radiographs available in the REPLI literature displayed an extended position of the scaphoid, a lunotriquetral dissociation, and a dorsal dislocation of the capitate with respect to the lunate. This study confirms our hypothesis. By contrast to the dorsal classic radial-sided pure ligamentous PLI pattern of scaphoid displacement (scaphoid flexed and foreshortened with scapholunate gap), the dorsal REPLI pattern displays an extended position of the scaphoid with scapholunate step-off and overlap rather than a gap. The combination of a lunotriquetral dissociation with a dorsal dislocation of the capitate from the lunate yet an extended position of the scaphoid with almost normal radioscaphoid relationships should raise a high suspicion for REPLI.
反月骨周围损伤(REPLI)是经典桡侧月骨周围损伤(PLI)的罕见变异类型,其损伤机制由梅菲尔德于1980年描述。经典的桡侧非经舟骨背侧PLI在最初的正位(PA)和侧位X线片上,舟骨总是呈现屈曲、缩短的位置。我们观察到一些背侧月骨周围脱位在其最初的X线片上舟骨呈现一种[此处原文缺失描述舟骨位置的词汇]位置。我们的假设是,舟骨的这种伸展位置与REPLI模式相关。 回顾了我们专业腕关节手术系列中114例背侧单纯韧带损伤性PLI(在2004年至2020年治疗的186例PLI病例系列中)的初始PA和侧位急诊X线片,以及当前REPLI文献中的可用数据。 在我们的背侧PLI系列中,共有7例病例在其最初的PA和侧位X线片上舟骨呈现伸展位置,而107例病例呈现屈曲、缩短位置。REPLI文献中可用的PA和侧位X线片显示舟骨伸展位置以及月三角骨分离,头状骨相对于月骨背侧脱位。 本研究证实了我们的假设。与背侧经典桡侧单纯韧带损伤性PLI的舟骨移位模式(舟骨屈曲、缩短且舟月间隙增宽)不同,背侧REPLI模式显示舟骨伸展位置,伴有舟月台阶样改变和重叠而非间隙。月三角骨分离以及头状骨相对于月骨背侧脱位,同时舟骨伸展位置且桡舟关系几乎正常,这种组合应高度怀疑为REPLI。