Department of Philosophy, William Paterson University of New Jersey, Wayne, New Jersey, USA.
Bioethics Program at FLACSO, CONICET, Buenos Aires, Argentina.
Bioethics. 2022 Jun;36(5):587-596. doi: 10.1111/bioe.13023. Epub 2022 Apr 28.
The concept of vulnerability is widely used in bioethics, particularly in research ethics and public health ethics. The traditional approach construes vulnerability as inherent in individuals or the groups to which they belong and views vulnerability as requiring special protections. Florencia Luna and other bioethicists continue to challenge traditional ways of conceptualizing and applying the term. Luna began proposing a layered approach to this concept and recently extended this proposal to offer two new concepts to analyze the concept of vulnerability, namely understanding external conditions that trigger vulnerability and layers of vulnerability with cascading effects. Luna's conception of vulnerability is useful, which we demonstrate by applying her layered view and the new analyses in multiple contexts. We begin by outlining Luna's view and we use vignettes from healthcare involving transgender patients, the care of patients in psychiatric contexts, and research involving prisoners to illustrate how each part of Luna's concept elucidates important moral issues.
易损性概念在生命伦理学中得到广泛应用,尤其是在研究伦理和公共卫生伦理中。传统的方法将易损性理解为个体或其所属群体固有的,并认为易损性需要特殊保护。弗洛伦西亚·卢娜(Florencia Luna)和其他生命伦理学家继续挑战传统的概念化和应用方式。卢娜开始提出一种分层方法来处理这个概念,最近又扩展了这个建议,提出了两个新的概念来分析易损性概念,即理解触发易损性的外部条件和具有级联效应的易损性层次。我们通过在多个上下文中应用她的分层观点和新的分析来证明卢娜易损性概念的有用性。我们首先概述卢娜的观点,然后使用涉及跨性别患者的医疗保健、精神病患者护理和涉及囚犯的研究的案例来说明卢娜概念的每一部分如何阐明重要的道德问题。