Cuartas Jorge
Harvard Graduate School of Education, Cambridge, MA, USA.
Department of Psychology, Universidad de los Andes, Bogotá, Colombia.
Child Psychiatry Hum Dev. 2023 Dec;54(6):1607-1623. doi: 10.1007/s10578-022-01362-3. Epub 2022 Apr 28.
Most studies and reviews of studies on the developmental consequences of corporal punishment have focused on samples from the U.S. and other high-income countries. This study conducted a rapid review of the literature on the associations between corporal punishment and children's cognitive and social-emotional development in low- and- middle-income countries (LMICs). Information from more than 42 studies of children younger than 18 years living in 64 LMICs was reviewed. Overall, the reviewed studies show associations between corporal punishment and negative cognitive and social-emotional outcomes, and there is no evidence that corporal punishment may relate to any positive developmental outcome in LMICs. Yet, issues of internal and external validity are common in the literature. The current evidence indicates that corporal punishment might increase the risk of detrimental child outcomes in LMICs, but further research with stronger methodological designs including samples from multiple settings is warranted.
大多数关于体罚对发育影响的研究及研究综述都聚焦于美国和其他高收入国家的样本。本研究对中低收入国家(LMICs)中体罚与儿童认知及社会情感发展之间关联的文献进行了快速综述。对来自64个中低收入国家的42项以上针对18岁以下儿童的研究信息进行了审查。总体而言,所审查的研究表明体罚与负面的认知及社会情感结果之间存在关联,并且没有证据表明体罚可能与中低收入国家的任何积极发展结果相关。然而,文献中普遍存在内部和外部效度问题。目前的证据表明,在中低收入国家,体罚可能会增加儿童出现有害结果的风险,但有必要开展方法设计更严谨的进一步研究,包括来自多种环境的样本。