Department of Mechanical Engineering, Zakir Husain College of Engineering & Technology, Aligarh Muslim University, Aligarh, India.
Department of Mechanical Engineering, Faculty of Engineering & Technology, Jamia Millia Islamia, New Delhi, India.
Int J Health Plann Manage. 2022 Sep;37(5):2635-2668. doi: 10.1002/hpm.3488. Epub 2022 Apr 28.
The goal of this research is to propose a simpler and more efficient model for evaluating healthcare establishments (HCEs). With this motivation, this study aims to discover key performance indicators (KPIs) that affect HCE performance, present a ranking model for KPIs in Indian HCEs, and evaluate Indian HCEs using the identified and prioritised KPIs.
Through extensive literature review and expert opinions, this research identifies the various KPIs in HCEs, classifies them into six main categories, and prioritises them using the full consistency method (FUCOM). Further, well-known HCEs across northern India were evaluated and ranked using Measurement Alternatives and Ranking according to Compromise Solution.
The 'technology adoption related indicators' is found as the most important main KPIs, whereas 'adequate number of hospital beds and bathrooms (IE5)' as the most dominating sub-category KPIs. Also, amongst the 20 evaluated Indian HCEs 'healthcare establishment-1 (HCE1)' was found to be the best performing HCE while 'healthcare establishment-12 (HCE12)' was found to be the worst-performing HCE. The stability and consistency of the results are ascertained by performing sensitivity analysis and comparing the results with other existing methodologies.
The findings of this study are quite important for HCEs management to fully comprehend the key areas to improve upon so that managers can improve medical standards in a targeted manner. The developed prioritisation model and methodology shown in this paper will help and motivate managers and intellectuals of HCEs to evaluate and improve the HCE's performance.
本研究旨在为医疗机构(HCE)的评估提出一个更简单、更有效的模型。基于这一动机,本研究旨在发现影响 HCE 绩效的关键绩效指标(KPI),提出印度 HCE 的 KPI 排名模型,并使用确定和优先排序的 KPI 来评估印度 HCE。
通过广泛的文献回顾和专家意见,本研究确定了 HCE 中的各种 KPI,将它们分为六个主要类别,并使用完全一致性方法(FUCOM)对其进行优先排序。此外,还使用妥协解排序的可替代衡量方法对印度北部的知名 HCE 进行了评估和排名。
“与技术采用相关的指标”被发现是最重要的主要 KPI,而“医院病床和浴室数量充足(IE5)”是最具主导地位的子类别 KPI。此外,在所评估的 20 家印度 HCE 中,“医疗机构 1(HCE1)”被发现是表现最好的 HCE,而“医疗机构 12(HCE12)”被发现是表现最差的 HCE。通过进行敏感性分析并将结果与其他现有方法进行比较,确定了结果的稳定性和一致性。
本研究的结果对于 HCE 管理非常重要,可帮助其全面了解需要改进的关键领域,以便管理者能够有针对性地提高医疗标准。本文提出的优先级排序模型和方法将有助于激励 HCE 的管理者和知识分子评估和提高 HCE 的绩效。