Senn H J
Arch Geschwulstforsch. 1986;56(6):425-33.
Initially somewhat exaggerated expectations about increased cure rates from adjuvant chemotherapy in operable breast cancer have been fulfilled only partially up to this date. However, most of the randomized, prospective and all of the historically controlled trials have revealed significantly decreased relapse and (less impressive) also death rates (expected mortality ratio) 5 and more years after mastectomy. Not all patient subgroups seem to benefit equally from adjuvant chemotherapy: its effectiveness seems to be more pronounced in pre- than in post-menopausal women and in those with only 1-3 instead of 4 and more tumor-positive homolateral axillary lymph nodes. Adjuvant combination chemotherapy seems to be more effective than monochemotherapy. Shortening of adjuvant CMF from 12 to 6 cycles gives the same result with definitely less toxicity. Adjuvant Tamoxifen probably is yielding similar results as adjuvant CMF (or other combinations) in post-menopausal, hormone-receptor positive women, but neither its long-term impact on survival nor the necessary treatment duration with antiestrogens are clearly known today. The value of adjuvant chemo- and hormone-therapy in node-negative women is still controversial, although at least hormone-receptor negative, node-negative patients exhibit the same risk of relapse and ultimate prognosis as do node-positive women. After 8-15 years of median follow-up in controlled studies, there seems to be no increased, but rather a decreased risk of second malignancies and also late leukemias in women treated with temporary adjuvant chemotherapy. Optimizing effectiveness and practicability of adjuvant chemo- (and also hormono-) therapy requires additional carefully controlled clinical studies, especially in high risk patients with more than 3 tumor-positive axillary nodes.
最初,人们对可手术乳腺癌辅助化疗治愈率提高的期望有些过高,而截至目前这些期望仅部分得到实现。然而,大多数随机、前瞻性试验以及所有历史对照试验均显示,乳房切除术后5年及更长时间,复发率显著降低,死亡率(预期死亡率)也有所下降(但降幅不太明显)。并非所有患者亚组似乎都能从辅助化疗中同等程度地获益:绝经前女性比绝经后女性、有1 - 3个而非4个及更多肿瘤阳性同侧腋窝淋巴结的女性,辅助化疗的效果似乎更显著。辅助联合化疗似乎比单一化疗更有效。将辅助性CMF方案从12个周期缩短至6个周期,疗效相同,但毒性明显降低。对于绝经后、激素受体阳性的女性,辅助性他莫昔芬可能产生与辅助性CMF(或其他联合方案)相似的结果,但目前尚不清楚其对生存的长期影响以及抗雌激素治疗的必要疗程。辅助化疗和激素治疗对淋巴结阴性女性的价值仍存在争议,尽管至少激素受体阴性、淋巴结阴性的患者与淋巴结阳性女性具有相同的复发风险和最终预后。在对照研究进行了8 - 15年的中位随访后,接受临时辅助化疗的女性发生第二原发性恶性肿瘤以及晚期白血病的风险似乎并未增加,反而有所降低。要优化辅助化疗(以及激素治疗)的有效性和实用性,需要进行更多精心对照的临床研究,尤其是针对有3个以上肿瘤阳性腋窝淋巴结的高危患者。