Department of Surgery, Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center, Boston, Massachusetts; Department of Surgery, Harvard Medical School, Boston, Massachusetts.
Department of Surgery, Harvard Medical School, Boston, Massachusetts; Department of Medicine, Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center, Boston, Massachusetts.
J Surg Res. 2022 Sep;277:116-124. doi: 10.1016/j.jss.2022.04.011. Epub 2022 Apr 27.
The discovery of apolipoprotein L1 (ApoL1) has raised important ethical and clinical questions about genetic testing in the context of living and deceased kidney donation. Largely missing from this discussion are the perspectives of those African Americans (AA) most likely to be impacted by ApoL1 testing.
We surveyed 331 AA potential and former living kidney donors (LKDs), kidney transplant candidates and recipients, and nonpatients at three United States transplant programs about their ApoL1 testing attitudes.
Overall, 72% felt that transplant programs should offer ApoL1 testing to AA potential LKDs. If a potential LKD has the high-risk genotype, 79% felt that the LKD should be allowed to make their own donation decision or participate in shared decision-making with transplant doctors. More than half of the potential LKDs (58%) would undergo ApoL1 testing and 81% of former LKDs would take the test now if offered. Most transplant candidates expressed a low likelihood of accepting a kidney from a LKD (79%) or a deceased donor (67%) with the high-risk genotype.
There is strong support among LKDs and transplant patients for ApoL1 testing when evaluating potential kidney donors of African ancestry. Inclusion of AA stakeholders in developing guidelines and educational programs for ApoL1 testing is critical.
载脂蛋白 L1(ApoL1)的发现引发了在活体和已故肾脏捐献背景下进行基因检测的重要伦理和临床问题。在这一讨论中,很大程度上忽略了那些最有可能受到 ApoL1 检测影响的非裔美国人(AA)的观点。
我们在美国三个移植项目中调查了 331 名 AA 潜在和前活体肾脏供者(LKD)、肾移植候选人和受者以及非患者,了解他们对 ApoL1 检测的态度。
总体而言,72%的人认为移植项目应该为 AA 潜在 LKD 提供 ApoL1 检测。如果潜在 LKD 具有高危基因型,79%的人认为 LKD 应该能够做出自己的捐赠决定,或与移植医生共同做出决策。超过一半的潜在 LKD(58%)会接受 ApoL1 检测,如果提供检测,81%的前 LKD 现在会接受检测。大多数移植候选者表示不太可能接受具有高危基因型的 LKD(79%)或已故供者(67%)的肾脏。
在评估非裔供者的潜在肾脏供者时,LKD 和移植患者对 ApoL1 检测有强烈的支持。在制定 ApoL1 检测指南和教育计划时,纳入 AA 利益相关者至关重要。