Kimpe Eva, Werbrouck Amber, De Ridder Mark, Putman Koen
Interuniversity Centre for Health Economics Research (I-CHER), Department of Public Health, Vrije Universiteit Brussel, Brussels, Belgium.
Department of Radiotherapy, Universitair Ziekenhuis Brussel, Vrije Universiteit Brussel, Brussels, Belgium.
Front Oncol. 2022 Apr 12;12:869529. doi: 10.3389/fonc.2022.869529. eCollection 2022.
Radiation-induced cardiotoxicity is an important health concern for clinicians during treatment of breast cancer (BC) patients. Underlying mechanisms are well-documented, whereas little is known about the societal impact of this long-term effect. This study aimed to quantify the additional burden of radiation-induced cardiovascular (CV) diseases in BC survivors.
Conventional health economic modelling techniques were applied to estimate attributed CV-related costs and disutility in a hypothetical cohort of BC survivors. A situation in which radiotherapy caused an additional CV risk was compared with a situation in which this risk was not taken into account. Uncertainty was assessed deterministic and probabilistic sensitivity analyses. Analyses were performed from a broad societal perspective up until 20 years after BC treatment.
Radiation-induced cardiotoxicity evokes a mean incremental cost of €275.10 per woman over a time horizon of 20 years after BC treatment. An additional decrement of 0.017 QALYs (per woman) might be expected when taking the radiation-induced cardiotoxic risk into account in BC survivors. Incremental costs and disutility increased with age. A scenario analysis showed that these results were more profound in women with more advanced staging.
Our analyses suggest that with current radiation techniques, rather minor costs and disutility are to be expected from radiation-induced cardiotoxicity in BC survivors. The cost of past investments in order to achieve current mean heart dose (MHD) seems justified when considering the gains from cost and disutility reduction resulting from radiation-induced cardiovascular events. The question we might consider is whether future opportunity costs associated with investments on further technological advancements offset the expected marginal benefit from further reducing the MHD.
在乳腺癌(BC)患者治疗过程中,辐射诱发的心脏毒性是临床医生关注的重要健康问题。其潜在机制已有充分记录,但对于这种长期影响的社会影响却知之甚少。本研究旨在量化BC幸存者中辐射诱发的心血管(CV)疾病的额外负担。
应用传统的健康经济建模技术,估计BC幸存者假设队列中归因于CV的相关成本和效用损失。将放疗导致额外CV风险的情况与未考虑此风险的情况进行比较。通过确定性和概率敏感性分析评估不确定性。从广泛的社会角度进行分析,直至BC治疗后20年。
在BC治疗后的20年时间范围内,辐射诱发的心脏毒性使每位女性的平均增量成本为275.10欧元。在考虑BC幸存者辐射诱发的心脏毒性风险时,预计每位女性的QALY会额外减少0.017。增量成本和效用损失随年龄增加。情景分析表明,这些结果在分期更晚的女性中更为显著。
我们的分析表明,采用当前的放疗技术,BC幸存者因辐射诱发的心脏毒性预计只会产生较小的成本和效用损失。考虑到辐射诱发的心血管事件在成本和效用损失降低方面的收益,为实现当前平均心脏剂量(MHD)而进行的过去投资成本似乎是合理的。我们可能要考虑的问题是,未来与进一步技术进步投资相关的机会成本是否会抵消进一步降低MHD所带来的预期边际效益。