Division of Anaesthesia, Department of Medicine, University of Cambridge, Cambridge, UK
NIHR Global Health Research Group for Neurotrauma, University of Cambridge, Cambridge, UK.
BMJ Open. 2022 May 9;12(5):e059935. doi: 10.1136/bmjopen-2021-059935.
Traumatic brain injury (TBI) is a global health problem, whose management in low-resource settings is hampered by fragile health systems and lack of access to specialist services. Improvement is complex, given the interaction of multiple people, processes and institutions. We aimed to develop a mixed-method approach to understand the TBI pathway based on the lived experience of local people, supported by quantitative methodologies and to determine potential improvement targets.
We describe a systems approach based on narrative exploration, participatory diagramming, data collection and discrete event simulation (DES), conducted by an international research collaborative.
The study is set in the tertiary neurotrauma centre in Yangon General Hospital, Myanmar, in 2019-2020 (prior to the SARS-CoV2 pandemic).
The qualitative work involved 40 workshop participants and 64 interviewees to explore the views of a wide range of stakeholders including staff, patients and relatives. The 1-month retrospective admission snapshot covered 85 surgical neurotrauma admissions.
The TBI pathway was outlined, with system boundaries defined around the management of TBI once admitted to the neurosurgical unit. Retrospective data showed 18% mortality, 71% discharge to home and an 11% referral rate. DES was used to investigate the system, showing its vulnerability to small surges in patient numbers, with critical points being CT scanning and observation ward beds. This explorative model indicated that a modest expansion of observation ward beds to 30 would remove the flow-limitations and indicated possible consequences of changes.
A systems approach to improving TBI care in resource-poor settings may be supported by simulation and informed by qualitative work to ground it in the direct experience of those involved. Narrative interviews, participatory diagramming and DES represent one possible suite of methods deliverable within an international partnership. Findings can support targeted improvement investments despite coexisting resource limitations while indicating concomitant risks.
创伤性脑损伤(TBI)是一个全球性的健康问题,在资源匮乏的环境中,由于脆弱的卫生系统和缺乏专科服务,其管理受到阻碍。鉴于涉及到多个人员、流程和机构的相互作用,改善情况非常复杂。我们旨在开发一种混合方法,基于当地人的生活体验来了解 TBI 通路,同时辅以定量方法,并确定潜在的改进目标。
我们描述了一种基于叙事探索、参与式绘图、数据收集和离散事件模拟(DES)的系统方法,该方法由一个国际研究合作开展。
该研究于 2019-2020 年在缅甸仰光总医院的三级神经创伤中心进行(在 SARS-CoV2 大流行之前)。
定性工作涉及 40 名研讨会参与者和 64 名受访者,以探索广泛利益相关者(包括工作人员、患者和家属)的观点。为期一个月的回顾性入院快照涵盖了 85 例神经外科创伤入院病例。
TBI 通路被勾勒出来,系统边界被定义为患者一旦被收入神经外科病房后的 TBI 管理。回顾性数据显示,死亡率为 18%,71%出院回家,转诊率为 11%。DES 用于研究该系统,表明其对患者人数的少量增加非常脆弱,关键问题是 CT 扫描和观察病房床位。这个探索性模型表明,将观察病房床位适度增加到 30 张可以消除流程限制,并表明了改变可能带来的后果。
在资源匮乏的环境中改善 TBI 护理的系统方法可以通过模拟得到支持,并通过与参与者的直接经验联系起来,通过定性工作使其具有实际意义。叙事访谈、参与式绘图和 DES 代表了一种可能的方法套件,可以在国际合作中实施。尽管存在资源限制,但调查结果可以支持有针对性的改进投资,同时还可以指出随之而来的风险。