Reade J M, Ratzan R M
N Engl J Med. 1987 May 21;316(21):1315-9. doi: 10.1056/NEJM198705213162106.
We compared the specialty listings of physicians in the Yellow Pages of the 1983 Hartford, Connecticut, telephone book with the board certifications in specialties of the American Board of Medical Specialties as listed in the American Medical Association directory or the Marquis Directory of Medical Specialists. There were 1179 listings by 946 physicians under 61 specialty headings in the Yellow Pages. We found that a mean of 12 percent of "specialists" listed in the Yellow Pages were not board-certified in a specialty, although they had had ample opportunity to obtain board certification. We conclude that specialty advertising in the Yellow Pages is potentially misleading to consumers and that member boards of the American Board of Medical Specialties should consider ways to diminish this possible misrepresentation.
我们将1983年康涅狄格州哈特福德市电话簿黄页中医生的专业名录,与美国医学协会名录或《医学专家 Marquis 名录》中列出的美国医学专业委员会的专业认证进行了比较。黄页中有946名医生在61个专业标题下列出了1179条名录。我们发现,黄页中列出的“专家”平均有12%没有获得某一专业的委员会认证,尽管他们有足够的机会获得委员会认证。我们得出结论,黄页中的专业广告可能会误导消费者,美国医学专业委员会的成员委员会应该考虑采取措施减少这种可能的不实陈述。