Mohamoud Gulnaz, Mash Robert
Division of Family Medicine and Primary Care, Stellenbosch University, Stellenbosch, South Africa
Department of Family Medicine, Aga Khan University, Nairobi, Kenya.
BJGP Open. 2022 Sep 28;6(3). doi: 10.3399/BJGPO.2021.0235. Print 2022 Sep.
High-quality primary care needs to be person-centred, and GPs must communicate effectively to ensure continuity and coordination of care. In Kenya, there is little knowledge about the quality of communication in consultations by GPs.
To evaluate the quality of communication in consultations by GPs.
DESIGN & SETTING: Descriptive, observational study of 23 GP consultations in 13 private sector primary care facilities in Nairobi, Kenya.
One consultation with a randomly selected adult patient was recorded per GP, and 16 communication skills evaluated with the Stellenbosch University Observation Tool (SUOT). A total percentage score was calculated per consultation, and compared with the GPs' demographics and the consultation complexity and duration using the Statistical Package for Social Sciences (SPSS, version 25).
The GPs' median age was 30.0 years (interquartile range [IQR] 29.0-32.0) and median consultation time was 7.0 minutes (IQR 3.0-9.0). Median overall score was 64.3% (IQR 48.4-75.7). GPs demonstrated skills in gathering information, making and explaining the diagnosis, and suggesting appropriate management. GPs did not make an appropriate introduction, explore the context or patients' perspectives, allow shared decision making, or provide adequate safety netting. There was a positive correlation between the scores and duration of the consultations ( = 0.680; = 0.001). The score was higher in consultations of moderate complexity (78.1, IQR 57.1-86.7) versus low complexity (52.2, IQR 45.1-66.6) ( = 0.012).
Consultations were brief and biomedical by young GPs. GPs need further training in communication skills, particularly with regard to delivering person-centred consultations. Deploying family physicians to the primary care setting would also improve the overall quality of service delivery.
高质量的初级医疗需要以患者为中心,全科医生必须进行有效的沟通,以确保医疗服务的连续性和协调性。在肯尼亚,对于全科医生会诊时的沟通质量了解甚少。
评估全科医生会诊时的沟通质量。
对肯尼亚内罗毕13家私立初级医疗设施中的23次全科医生会诊进行描述性观察研究。
每位全科医生随机选取一名成年患者的一次会诊进行记录,使用斯泰伦博斯大学观察工具(SUOT)评估16项沟通技巧。计算每次会诊的总百分比得分,并使用社会科学统计软件包(SPSS,版本25)将其与全科医生的人口统计学特征、会诊复杂性和时长进行比较。
全科医生的年龄中位数为30.0岁(四分位间距[IQR]为29.0 - 32.0),会诊时间中位数为7.0分钟(IQR为3.0 - 9.0)。总体得分中位数为64.3%(IQR为48.4 - 75.7)。全科医生在收集信息、做出并解释诊断以及提出适当的管理建议方面表现出一定技巧。全科医生未进行恰当的介绍,未探究背景情况或患者观点,未进行共同决策,也未提供充分的安全保障。得分与会诊时长呈正相关( = 0.680; = 0.001)。中等复杂性会诊的得分(78.1,IQR为57.1 - 86.7)高于低复杂性会诊(52.2,IQR为45.1 - 66.6)( = 0.012)。
年轻的全科医生会诊时间简短且偏向生物医学模式。全科医生需要在沟通技巧方面接受进一步培训,尤其是在提供以患者为中心的会诊方面。在初级医疗环境中部署家庭医生也将提高整体服务质量。