Communication Disorders and Sciences Program, University of Oregon, Eugene.
Lang Speech Hear Serv Sch. 2022 Jul 6;53(3):786-802. doi: 10.1044/2022_LSHSS-21-00142. Epub 2022 May 12.
In this clinical focus article, we discuss the nature of critical thinking, its importance for adolescents, and its interaction with later language development. We also introduce a language arts program, . The program aims to support critical thinking, narrative and expository discourse, and the use of complex syntax and literate vocabulary.
In designing , we examined research from education, psychology, philosophy, and speech-language pathology in the areas of critical thinking and narrative discourse. The resulting program encourages students to think independently, listen to others, offer reasons and evidence to support their views, and express themselves with accuracy, clarity, and efficiency. Implementation is illustrated with a case study of a 12-year-old girl.
Although critical thinking improves during adolescence, many students struggle in this area, particularly in the ability to offer reasons and evidence to support their views. This suggests that these adolescents could benefit from instruction in critical thinking. Research also indicates that competence in critical thinking is associated with narrative and expository discourse, and with the use of complex syntax and literate words such as metacognitive verbs. Instruction using may be carried out in small groups or individually by a speech-language pathologist working collaboratively with a teacher, teaching assistant, or other professional. Designed for flexible application, the program may be used with adolescents who have language disorders and those who have typical language development.
Research is necessary to evaluate the program with students from diverse backgrounds, having differing levels of language competence and academic achievement.
在这篇临床重点文章中,我们讨论了批判性思维的本质、它对青少年的重要性以及它与后期语言发展的相互作用。我们还介绍了一个语言艺术项目。该计划旨在支持批判性思维、叙事和说明性话语,以及使用复杂的语法和有文化素养的词汇。
在设计 时,我们研究了来自教育、心理学、哲学和言语-语言病理学领域的关于批判性思维和叙事话语的研究。该计划鼓励学生独立思考、倾听他人的意见、提供理由和证据来支持他们的观点,并以准确、清晰和高效的方式表达自己。通过对一名 12 岁女孩的案例研究来说明实施情况。
尽管批判性思维在青少年时期有所提高,但许多学生在这方面存在困难,特别是在提供理由和证据来支持他们的观点的能力方面。这表明这些青少年可能受益于批判性思维的指导。研究还表明,批判性思维能力与叙事和说明性话语以及使用复杂语法和有文化素养的词汇(如元认知动词)有关。使用 进行的教学可以由言语-语言病理学家在小组中或与教师、助教或其他专业人员合作进行个别教学。该计划设计灵活,可用于有语言障碍和语言发展正常的青少年。
有必要对来自不同背景、具有不同语言能力和学业成绩的学生进行研究,以评估该计划。