Liebold Felix, Hippler Catherina, Schmitz Jan, Yücetepe Sirin, Rothschild Markus, Hinkelbein Jochen
Aerosp Med Hum Perform. 2022 May 1;93(5):442-449. doi: 10.3357/AMHP.5977.2022.
There is a paucity of research on general aviation accidents in Germany. The authorities investigate only a fraction of all national accidents. The current study analyzes existing accident reports and aims to identify injury severity in regard to concomitant risk factors. Data of flight accidents was analyzed for aircraft of <5700 kg maximum takeoff weight (MTOW) over a 20-yr period. Besides descriptive data, concomitant factors (type and category of aircraft, date, occupants and outcome, flight phase, etc.) were analyzed. Statistical analysis was performed using the Chi-squared test. The authorities list 1595 aircraft accidents between 2000 and 2019, but only 17.9% of these were analyzed in detail. Accidents of aircraft of <2000 kg MTOW were over-represented between May and September and between Friday and Sunday. The fraction of fatal accidents was highest during cruise. During landing, significantly more mishaps of larger aircraft occurred. The number of seriously injured or deceased occupants was significantly higher for accidents involving private pilots. An occupancy rate of more than three persons on board correlated significantly with fewer number of deaths. The annual count of aircraft accidents has almost halved during the previous 20 yr. Unfortunately, only a small number of mishaps were further investigated by authorities, which leads to a lack of evaluable data needed for in-depth investigations. The accumulation of larger aircraft mishaps in winter and the superior outcome of professional pilots in terms of safety, as well as the fewer number of mishaps in larger aircraft, should be further investigated.
德国对通用航空事故的研究较少。当局只对全国所有事故中的一小部分进行调查。当前的研究分析了现有的事故报告,旨在确定与伴随风险因素相关的伤害严重程度。对20年期间最大起飞重量(MTOW)<5700千克的飞机的飞行事故数据进行了分析。除了描述性数据外,还分析了伴随因素(飞机类型和类别、日期、乘客和结果、飞行阶段等)。使用卡方检验进行统计分析。当局列出了2000年至2019年期间的1595起飞机事故,但其中只有17.9%进行了详细分析。MTOW<2000千克的飞机事故在5月至9月以及周五至周日期间的占比过高。致命事故的比例在巡航期间最高。在着陆期间,较大型飞机发生的事故明显更多。涉及私人飞行员的事故中,受重伤或死亡的乘客数量明显更高。机上乘客人数超过三人与死亡人数减少显著相关。在过去20年中,飞机事故的年数量几乎减半。不幸的是,当局只对少数事故进行了进一步调查,这导致缺乏深入调查所需的可评估数据。冬季大型飞机事故的积累、专业飞行员在安全方面的更好结果以及大型飞机事故较少的情况,应进一步调查。