School of Water Resource and Environment, Beijing Key Laboratory of Water Resources and Environmental Engineering, and MOE Key Laboratory of Groundwater Circulation and Environmental Evolution, China University of Geosciences (Beijing), Beijing 100083, China.
Jiangxi Province Architectural Design & Research Institute, Nanchang 330000, China.
Sci Total Environ. 2022 Sep 10;838(Pt 1):155905. doi: 10.1016/j.scitotenv.2022.155905. Epub 2022 May 13.
Natural background levels (NBLs) is a prerequisite for distinguishing anthropogenic groundwater pollution and judging the evolution of groundwater quality. However, due to regional differences of hydrogeochemitry and water-rock interaction, coupled with long-term anthropogenic activities, it is no longer accurate to assess NBLs with only statistical methods or without considering human impact. Herein, multi-hydrochemical and statistical methods were examined to identify apparent background levels and anthropogenic anomalous activities of shallow groundwater by selecting Liujiang Basin as a study area. The results showed that the differences in hydrochemical characteristics among each hydrogeological unit (HU) fully illustrated the necessity of rationally dividing HU for background value identification. The application of the concept of apparent background levels (ABLs), that is, incorporating normal human activities into the background levels, efficiently solved the problem of being unable to obtain pristine NBLs due to long-term human activities. The coupling of Hydrochemistry and Grubbs' test (Hydro-Grubbs) was confirmed as the optimal method in identifying and eliminating anthropogenic groundwater anomalies, performing sufficiently superiority when compared with purely statistical methods. It is mainly because the Hydro-Grubbs method not only considers the discreteness of the data itself, but also considers the internal connection and evolution process of the hydrochemical compositions. For the eliminated abnormal points, 91.0-93.6% of which have been effectively explained by pollution percentage index and the impact of coal mining, industrial activities, residents, agricultural activities, and septic tanks leakage, proving the rationality and reliability of Hydro-Grubbs method and ABLs evaluation result. This finding will assist in accurately identifying anthropogenic pollution on a regional scale and guiding future efforts to protect groundwater resources.
自然背景水平(NBL)是区分人为地下水污染和判断地下水质量演变的前提。然而,由于区域水文地球化学和水岩相互作用的差异,再加上长期的人为活动,仅用统计方法或不考虑人为影响来评估 NBL 已经不再准确。因此,选择柳江流域作为研究区,采用多水化学和统计方法,通过识别明显背景水平和浅层地下水人为异常活动,对人为异常活动进行评估。结果表明,各水文地质单元(HU)之间的水化学特征差异充分说明了合理划分 HU 进行背景值识别的必要性。表观背景水平(ABL)概念的应用,即将正常人为活动纳入背景值中,有效地解决了由于长期人为活动而无法获得原始 NBL 的问题。水化学与格鲁布斯检验(Hydro-Grubbs)的耦合被确认为识别和消除人为地下水异常的最佳方法,与纯粹的统计方法相比具有足够的优势。这主要是因为 Hydro-Grubbs 方法不仅考虑了数据本身的离散性,还考虑了水化学成分的内部联系和演化过程。对于消除的异常点,其中 91.0-93.6%已通过污染百分比指数和采煤、工业活动、居民、农业活动以及化粪池泄漏的影响得到有效解释,证明了 Hydro-Grubbs 方法和 ABL 评估结果的合理性和可靠性。这一发现将有助于在区域尺度上准确识别人为污染,并指导未来保护地下水资源的工作。