Division of Clinical Therapies, Nationwide Children's Hospital, Columbus, OH.
Department of Biomedical Informatics, Center for Biostatistics, The Ohio State University Wexner Medical Center, Columbus.
Am J Speech Lang Pathol. 2022 Jul 12;31(4):1601-1610. doi: 10.1044/2022_AJSLP-21-00298. Epub 2022 May 17.
The International Dysphagia Diet Standardisation Initiative (IDDSI) framework was established to provide standardized terminology and objective measures to assess foods and liquids for persons with swallowing difficulties. This clinical focus article reports the findings and clinical implications of the flow testing of infant formulas thickened with infant cereal completed as part of the transition process to IDDSI for one large pediatric quaternary care hospital.
To determine a common recipe that could be used to thicken formulas with infant cereal to the appropriate IDDSI levels, three clinicians completed flow testing on 94 infant formulas. To examine intra- and interclinician variability in the process, they repeated flow testing with three commonly used formulas and infant cereal.
Clinicians were unable to identify a standard recipe (infant formula + infant cereal combination) that consistently thickened different formula brands to a desired IDDSI thickness level, as there was pronounced variability across and within infant formulas. Reliability testing revealed that, overall, clinician mixers were consistent in replicating similar results to themselves and to each other and that, instead, greater variability lies within the formula (and infant formula + infant cereal combination).
Based on findings of pronounced variability within and across infant formulas, our institution determined that the creation of a standard recipe for achieving IDDSI thickness levels of formula mixed with infant cereal was not feasible or clinically appropriate. We offer recommendations for similar institutions for advancing clinical management of infant dysphagia using the IDDSI flow test and directions for future research.
国际吞咽障碍饮食标准化倡议 (IDDSI) 框架的建立旨在为吞咽困难者提供评估食物和液体的标准化术语和客观测量方法。本文是一篇临床重点文章,报告了为向 IDDSI 过渡而对一家大型儿科四级保健医院的婴儿配方奶粉进行增稠的婴儿谷物的流量测试的结果和临床意义。
为了确定可以用于将婴儿谷物增稠至适当 IDDSI 水平的通用配方,三位临床医生对 94 种婴儿配方奶粉进行了流量测试。为了检查该过程中临床医生之间的个体差异,他们使用三种常用的配方和婴儿谷物重复了流量测试。
临床医生无法确定一种标准配方(婴儿配方奶粉+婴儿谷物的组合),能够将不同品牌的配方奶粉始终增稠至所需的 IDDSI 稠度水平,因为不同配方奶粉之间存在明显的差异。可靠性测试表明,总体而言,混合配方的临床医生在复制自己和彼此相似的结果方面是一致的,而更大的差异存在于配方(和婴儿配方奶粉+婴儿谷物的组合)中。
基于配方内和配方间存在明显差异的发现,我们机构确定,为实现婴儿配方奶粉与婴儿谷物混合的 IDDSI 稠度水平创建标准配方是不可行或临床不合适的。我们为类似机构提供了使用 IDDSI 流量测试进行婴儿吞咽障碍临床管理的建议,并为未来的研究提供了方向。