Scharpf Florian, Kızıltepe Rukiye, Kirika Anette, Hecker Tobias
Department of Psychology, Bielefeld University, Bielefeld, Germany.
Institute for Interdisciplinary Research on Conflict and Violence, Bielefeld University, Bielefeld, Germany.
Trauma Violence Abuse. 2023 Oct;24(4):2581-2597. doi: 10.1177/15248380221102559. Epub 2022 May 18.
There is increasing evidence for the deleterious impact of emotional violence on children`s well-being and development. This systematic review focused on a) the prevalence and (b) correlates of emotional violence by teachers. A literature search of quantitative and peer-reviewed studies published in English between 1980 and April 2021 was conducted. Eighty-four studies met the inclusion criteria. Studies represented all geographical regions of the world, were predominantly cross-sectional and of moderate quality. Studies were heterogeneous in terms of their samples, conceptualization, and measurement of emotional violence. Results indicated that emotional violence by teachers is prevalent across cultural settings, although large variations within and between regions are noted. It is related to mental health, behavioral and academic problems of children above and beyond physical violence by teachers and victimization by peers and parents. Boys are at higher risk of experiencing emotional violence by teachers than girls. Family dysfunction, low socioeconomic status (of the family or the community), and violent school environments appear to increase risk as well. The observed patterns of co-occurrence of emotional violence with physical violence by teachers and victimization by peers as well as perpetration of violence against peers and teachers lend support to notions of poly-victimization and cycles of violence in the school settings. Future research should use representative surveys, examine antecedents, and consequences of emotional violence by teachers using longitudinal and experimental designs and evaluate interventions to prevent emotional violence by teachers.
越来越多的证据表明,情感暴力对儿童的幸福和发展具有有害影响。本系统综述聚焦于:(a)教师实施情感暴力的发生率,以及(b)与之相关的因素。我们对1980年至2021年4月期间发表的英文定量研究和同行评审研究进行了文献检索。84项研究符合纳入标准。这些研究涵盖了世界所有地理区域,主要为横断面研究,质量中等。这些研究在情感暴力的样本、概念化和测量方面存在异质性。结果表明,尽管各区域内部和区域之间存在很大差异,但教师实施的情感暴力在各种文化背景中都很普遍。它与儿童的心理健康、行为和学业问题有关,且超出了教师的身体暴力以及同伴和父母的伤害行为的影响。男孩比女孩遭受教师情感暴力的风险更高。家庭功能失调、(家庭或社区的)社会经济地位低下以及暴力的学校环境似乎也会增加风险。观察到的情感暴力与教师身体暴力、同伴伤害行为同时发生的模式,以及对同伴和教师实施暴力的情况,支持了学校环境中多重受害和暴力循环的观点。未来的研究应采用代表性调查,运用纵向和实验设计研究教师情感暴力的前因和后果,并评估预防教师情感暴力的干预措施。