Department of Psychology, University of Washington.
Department of Psychology, University of Massachusetts.
Psychol Sci Public Interest. 2022 May;23(1):7-40. doi: 10.1177/15291006211070781.
Accumulated findings from studies in which implicit-bias measures correlate with discriminatory judgment and behavior have led many social scientists to conclude that implicit biases play a causal role in racial and other discrimination. In turn, that belief has promoted and sustained two lines of work to develop remedies: (a) individual treatment interventions expected to weaken or eradicate implicit biases and (b) group-administered training programs to overcome biases generally, including implicit biases. Our review of research on these two types of sought remedies finds that they lack established methods that durably diminish implicit biases and have not reproducibly reduced discriminatory consequences of implicit (or other) biases. That disappointing conclusion prompted our turn to strategies based on methods that have been successful in the domain of public health. are designed to disable the path from implicit biases to discriminatory outcomes. methods aim to discover disparities that sometimes have obvious fixes, or that at least suggest where responsibility should reside for developing a fix. Disparity-finding methods have the advantage of being useful in remediation not only for implicit biases but also systemic biases. For both of these categories of bias, causes of discriminatory outcomes are understood as residing in large part outside the conscious awareness of individual actors. We conclude with recommendations to guide organizations that wish to deal with biases for which they have not yet found solutions.
研究中积累的发现表明,内隐偏见与歧视性判断和行为相关,这使得许多社会科学家得出结论,内隐偏见在种族和其他歧视中起着因果作用。反过来,这种信念又促进和维持了两条工作线来开发补救措施:(a)预计可以削弱或消除内隐偏见的个体治疗干预措施,以及(b)旨在克服偏见的群体管理培训计划,包括内隐偏见。我们对这两种类型的补救措施的研究进行了回顾,发现它们缺乏持久减少内隐偏见的既定方法,也没有可重复地减少内隐(或其他)偏见的歧视后果。这一令人失望的结论促使我们转向基于已在公共卫生领域取得成功的方法的策略。这些方法旨在阻止内隐偏见转化为歧视性结果的途径。发现差异的方法旨在发现有时有明显解决办法的差异,或者至少表明应该为制定解决办法承担责任的地方。发现差异的方法具有这样的优势,即不仅对内隐偏见,而且对系统偏见的补救都很有用。对于这两类偏见,歧视性结果的原因被理解为在很大程度上存在于个体行为者的意识之外。我们最后提出了建议,以指导那些希望处理尚未找到解决方案的偏见的组织。