Alotaibi Feras Zeyad, Agha Sajida, Masuadi Emad
Department of Medical Education, College of Medicine, King Saud bin Abdulaziz University for Health Sciences, Riyadh, Saudi Arabia.
King Abdullah International Medical Research Centre, Riyadh, Saudi Arabia.
Adv Med Educ Pract. 2022 May 13;13:507-519. doi: 10.2147/AMEP.S363187. eCollection 2022.
This study explores the healthcare educators' orientations about medical simulation in clinical skills training -its benefits, needs, challenges, and implications for proper implementation and integration into curricula.
The study used a Q-sort technique, allowing quantitative and qualitative representation of the participants' orientations and was conducted at King Saud bin Abdulaziz University for Health Sciences in Riyadh, Saudi Arabia. A total of 22 healthcare educators from different roles were included. Participants pre-sorted into three categories and then ranked statements related to medical simulation, by level of agreement, and they answered open-ended and demographic questions. Data was uploaded to Ken-Q Analysis application to conduct Q-factor analysis.
A total of 22 healthcare educators participated in the study. Q-factor analysis was performed with principal component analysis and varimax rotation, identifying three factors. Most educators shared a similar orientation regarding the benefits of using simulation-based learning. Most participants considered medical simulation a simple, effortless, and beneficial method of learning. However, challenges in scheduling sessions and obtaining the necessary resources, such as human resources and funds, and lack of training had a negative impact on some participants' motivation to use medical simulation.
Healthcare educators shed light on the influence of multiple factors on using medical simulation. The possibility for students to learn practical and clinical skills was a leading factor. Financial resources, funds, and faculty training were identified as challenges and needs. It is important for institutions and leaders to be aware of the variations in faculty perceptions and to provide resources and training to improve the current use of medical simulation.
本研究探讨了医疗保健教育工作者在临床技能培训中对医学模拟的看法——其益处、需求、挑战以及对正确实施和融入课程的影响。
本研究采用Q分类技术,能够对参与者的看法进行定量和定性呈现,研究在沙特阿拉伯利雅得的沙特国王阿卜杜勒阿齐兹健康科学大学进行。共有22名来自不同岗位的医疗保健教育工作者参与其中。参与者先被分为三类,然后根据认同程度对与医学模拟相关的陈述进行排序,并回答开放式问题和人口统计学问题。数据上传至Ken-Q分析应用程序以进行Q因素分析。
共有22名医疗保健教育工作者参与了本研究。通过主成分分析和方差最大化旋转进行Q因素分析,确定了三个因素。大多数教育工作者在基于模拟的学习的益处方面看法相似。大多数参与者认为医学模拟是一种简单、轻松且有益的学习方法。然而,安排课程以及获取必要资源(如人力资源和资金)方面的挑战以及缺乏培训对一些参与者使用医学模拟的积极性产生了负面影响。
医疗保健教育工作者揭示了多种因素对使用医学模拟的影响。学生学习实践和临床技能的可能性是一个主要因素。财政资源、资金和教师培训被确定为挑战和需求。机构和领导者了解教师认知的差异并提供资源和培训以改善当前医学模拟的使用情况非常重要。