Institute for Health Disparities, University of North Texas Health Science Center, 3500 Camp Bowie Blvd, Fort Worth, TX, 76107, USA.
University of the Incarnate Word School of Osteopathic Medicine, San Antonio, USA.
BMC Med Educ. 2022 May 21;22(1):391. doi: 10.1186/s12909-022-03466-9.
Increased awareness and mitigation of one's unconscious bias is a critical strategy in diversifying the Science, Technology, Engineering, Mathematics, and Medicine (STEMM) disciplines and workforce. Greater management of unconscious bias can enhance diverse recruitment, persistence, retention, and engagement of trainees. The purpose of this study was to describe the implementation of an asynchronous course on unconscious bias for people in STEMM. Specifically, we explored who engaged with the course and reflections from participation.
A five-part, asynchronous Unconscious Bias Course was developed and was hosted on a national mentoring platform starting in July 2020. To examine course engagement, we assessed the demographics of course participants and completion. Participant responses to reflection questions after each module were also synthesized using qualitative methods.
Overall, 977 people registered for the course and 42% completed all modules. In the reflection responses, participants reflected on their unconscious biases in their lived experiences and how it relates to actions, judgements, external factors, stereotypes, and un-intentionality. Participants also reflected on microaggressions, their impact on the recipients and others, and the relationship between microaggressions and unconscious bias. Participants reported four key strategies used by allies against unconscious bias: immediately acting (83%), reflection (46%), improving the organizational culture (30%), and individual-level ally-ship (44%). Strategies for self-awareness included: reflection, pausing/breathing, and self-observation.
The assessment of the Unconscious Bias Course implementation revealed the course reached a wide cross-section of people in STEMM and demonstrated that participants were able to reflect on the underpinnings of the course. This course, and its suite of offerings, support a nationwide effort to mitigate bias and prepare individuals to be culturally competent in a diverse society in order to foster a STEMM environment that caters to individuals' success and diversification of these fields.
提高对自身无意识偏见的认识并加以缓解,是使科学、技术、工程、数学和医学(STEMM)学科和劳动力多样化的关键策略。更好地管理无意识偏见可以促进多元化招聘,培养学员的坚持、保留和参与。本研究的目的是描述为 STEMM 领域的人员实施无意识偏见异步课程的情况。具体来说,我们探讨了谁参与了该课程以及从参与中得到的反馈。
开发了一个五部分的无意识偏见异步课程,并于 2020 年 7 月在一个全国性的指导平台上推出。为了评估课程参与度,我们评估了课程参与者的人口统计学特征和完成情况。还使用定性方法综合了参与者在每个模块后对反思问题的回答。
总体而言,有 977 人注册了该课程,其中 42%的人完成了所有模块。在反思性回应中,参与者反思了他们在生活经历中无意识偏见,以及其如何与行动、判断、外部因素、刻板印象和非意图相关。参与者还反思了微侵犯,它们对接受者和其他人的影响,以及微侵犯和无意识偏见之间的关系。参与者报告了四种盟友对抗无意识偏见的关键策略:立即采取行动(83%)、反思(46%)、改善组织文化(30%)和个人层面的盟友关系(44%)。自我意识的策略包括:反思、暂停/呼吸和自我观察。
对无意识偏见课程实施情况的评估表明,该课程吸引了 STEMM 领域的广泛人群,并且参与者能够反思课程的基础。该课程及其一系列课程为全国范围内缓解偏见和培养个人在多元化社会中的文化能力提供了支持,以促进一个能够满足个人成功和这些领域多样化需求的 STEMM 环境。