Herrick Clare, Kelly Ann, Soulard Jeanne
Department of Geography, King's College London London UK.
Department of Global Health and Social Medicine, King's College London London UK.
Trans Inst Br Geogr. 2022 Apr 28. doi: 10.1111/tran.12544.
COVID-19 is a multi-spectral crisis that has added an acute layer over a panoply of complex emergencies across the world. In the process, it has not only exposed actually-existing emergencies, but also exacerbated them as the global gaze has turned inward. As a crisis, COVID-19 straddles and challenges the boundaries between humanitarianism, development and global health - the frames and categories through which emergencies are so often understood and intervened upon. Reflection on these fundamental categories is, we argue, an important geographical endeavour. Drawing on Geoffrey Bowker's analytical lens of the 'infrastructural inversion', we explore how humanitarianism has been upended by Covid-19 along two axes that are of core concern to geographers: (1) the spatial; and (2) the temporal. We first contextualise current debates on the humanitarian endeavour and its future within recent geographical research. We then set out the complex structure by which COVID-19 has been both imagined and intervened upon as a humanitarian emergency. In so doing, we then pave the way for a deeper empirical analysis of the spatial and temporal inversions that have been brought forth by COVID-19. The paper concludes by examining the conceptual value of the 'inversion' in developing geographical research agendas better attuned to the increasing porosity of humanitarianism, development and global health.
新冠疫情是一场多层面的危机,它在全球一系列复杂的紧急情况之上又叠加了一层严峻形势。在此过程中,它不仅暴露了实际存在的紧急情况,还因全球目光转向国内而加剧了这些情况。作为一场危机,新冠疫情跨越并挑战了人道主义、发展和全球健康之间的界限——这些框架和类别常常是人们理解和应对紧急情况的方式。我们认为,对这些基本类别进行反思是一项重要的地理学研究。借助杰弗里·鲍克的“基础设施倒置”分析视角,我们探讨新冠疫情如何在地理学家最为关注的两个轴向上颠覆了人道主义:(1)空间;(2)时间。我们首先在近期地理学研究的背景下,阐述当前关于人道主义事业及其未来的辩论。然后,我们阐述新冠疫情被视为一场人道主义紧急情况并得到应对的复杂结构。在此过程中,我们为更深入地实证分析新冠疫情带来的空间和时间倒置铺平道路。本文最后探讨“倒置”在制定更符合人道主义、发展和全球健康日益融合趋势的地理学研究议程方面的概念价值。