International Centre for Evidence in Disability, London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine, London, UK.
Sheik Zahid Regional Eye Care Centre, Banjul, The Gambia.
J Laryngol Otol. 2022 Sep;136(9):839-847. doi: 10.1017/S0022215122001190. Epub 2022 May 24.
This study aimed to determine the implications of including tympanometry in the Rapid Assessment of Hearing Loss survey protocol. A comparative study design was employed, with findings from otoscopy compared with the results of tympanometry.
A population-based survey of the prevalence and causes of hearing loss among adults aged over 35 years in The Gambia was conducted. Clinical assessments included air conduction audiometry, otoscopy and clinical history. Otoscopy outcome was recorded and for those with hearing loss, a probable cause was assigned. Following otoscopy, tympanometry was completed. Otoscopy outcome was not changed as a result of tympanometry. Clinician assigned cause was compared to the results of tympanometry. The proportion of causes potentially misclassified by excluding tympanometry was determined.
Among people with hearing loss, including tympanometry led to a higher proportion diagnosed with middle-ear conditions.
The value of adding tympanometry to population-based survey protocols is a higher estimated proportion of hearing loss being attributed to middle-ear disease rather than sensorineural causes. This can inform service needs as more people will be classified as needing medical or surgical services, and a slightly lower number will need rehabilitative services, such as hearing assistive devices. It is highly recommended that tympanometry is included in the protocol.
本研究旨在确定将鼓室图纳入快速听力损失评估调查方案的意义。采用了对比研究设计,将鼓室图的结果与耳镜检查的结果进行比较。
在冈比亚进行了一项基于人群的 35 岁以上成年人听力损失的患病率和病因的调查。临床评估包括空气传导听力测试、耳镜检查和临床病史。记录耳镜检查结果,对于有听力损失的人,分配一个可能的病因。耳镜检查后,进行鼓室图检查。鼓室图检查结果不会因耳镜检查而改变。比较临床医生分配的病因与鼓室图的结果。确定因排除鼓室图而导致潜在误诊的病因比例。
在有听力损失的人群中,包括鼓室图检查在内,导致更多的人被诊断为中耳疾病。
将鼓室图添加到基于人群的调查方案中的价值在于,更多的听力损失被归因于中耳疾病而不是感觉神经性原因,这可以为服务需求提供信息,因为更多的人将被归类为需要医疗或手术服务,而较少的人将需要康复服务,如听力辅助设备。强烈建议在方案中纳入鼓室图检查。