Ferraiuolo Fabio, Dante Angelo, Petrucci Cristina, Güvenç Gülten, Lancia Loreto
Department of Health, Life and Environmental Sciences, University of L'Aquila, Edificio Rita Levi Montalcini, L'Aquila, Abruzzo, Italy.
Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology Nursing, Ankara University of Health Sciences, Faculty of Nursing, Ankara, Turkey.
Florence Nightingale J Nurs. 2022 Feb;30(1):48-54. doi: 10.5152/fnjn.2021.21075.
The study aimed at reporting the extent to which nurses in operating teams comply with the WHO's surgical safety checklist at the national level.
A total of 621 nurses who attended the conferences held by the Association of Italian Nurses in Operating Teams (AICO) in 2019 were selected as the sample group for this descriptive study. They filled a paper-based questionnaire of items, which were according to WHO's recommendations for surgical safety. Descriptive analyses were used to illustrate participants' characteristics and responses to the questionnaire. The chi-square test was used to outline the relation between participants' socio-cultural features and the information on the extent to which participants implemented the surgical safety checklist.
According to the data collected, a majority of the participants (95.2%) claimed to comply with the checklist in perioperative procedures. Moreover, most participants (63.2%) revealed that they revise the checklist according to specific circumstances affecting their workflow and/or operational team. Additionally, almost a third of participants (31.9%) stated that they undertake an oral completion of the steps in the checklist to ensure its effective implementation.
In this study, it emerged that the implementation of measures ensuring safety standards is largely inconsistent with the guidelines provided by WHO. Notably, major discrepancies occur when it comes to team members' coordination, the revision of the checklist according to specific circumstances, the oral completion of the checklist's steps during the workflow, and the active contribution of all team members in the implementation of the surgical safety checklist.
本研究旨在报告手术团队中的护士在国家层面遵守世界卫生组织手术安全核对表的程度。
选取2019年参加意大利手术团队护士协会(AICO)举办会议的621名护士作为该描述性研究的样本组。他们填写了一份纸质问卷,问卷项目依据世界卫生组织的手术安全建议制定。采用描述性分析来说明参与者的特征以及对问卷的回答。使用卡方检验来勾勒参与者的社会文化特征与关于参与者实施手术安全核对表程度的信息之间的关系。
根据收集到的数据,大多数参与者(95.2%)声称在围手术期程序中遵守核对表。此外,大多数参与者(63.2%)表示他们会根据影响其工作流程和/或手术团队的具体情况修订核对表。另外,近三分之一的参与者(31.9%)表示他们会口头完成核对表中的步骤以确保其有效实施。
在本研究中,确保安全标准的措施实施情况在很大程度上与世界卫生组织提供的指南不一致。值得注意的是,在团队成员协调、根据具体情况修订核对表、在工作流程中口头完成核对表步骤以及所有团队成员在实施手术安全核对表中的积极贡献方面存在重大差异。