Mitrovic Darko, Veeger Nic, van Roon Eric
Department of Hospital Pharmacy Tjongerschans, Heerenveen, The Netherlands.
Department of Pharmacotherapy, Epidemiology and Economy, Faculty Pharmacy, University of Groningen, Groningen, The Netherlands.
Curr Med Res Opin. 2022 Sep;38(9):1485-1488. doi: 10.1080/03007995.2022.2085963. Epub 2022 Jun 14.
In a previous study on the reasons for discontinuation of novel oral anticoagulation therapy (NOAC) in patients with atrial fibrillation, we showed that minor bleeding was the second most important reason for NOAC discontinuation. This finding suggest that the impact of minor bleeds on the patient's perspective on NOACs cannot be ignored, especially those minor bleeds for which the patient searched medical care. We therefore performed a study in which we explored the impact of minor bleed (clinically relevant non-major bleeds) on patient confidence in therapy, adherence to treatment and quality of life in AF patients using NOAC's.
Details on NOAC therapy, level of confidence, adherence and quality of life were assessed using a semi-structured telephone interview. Questions related to annoyance, concern and trust were scored on a scale of 1-10, with score 10 representing the highest level of impact or trust. For the adherence to treatment before and after a minor bleed the Medication Adherence Rating Scale (MARS-5) questionnaire was used. The total MARS-5 score ranges from 5 to 25; score 5 is indicative of poor adherence and 25 suggest perfect adherence. Furthermore, the impact (restrictions) of a bleed on physical activities and daily life was assessed using a VAS score ranging from 1 to 10; score 10 representing the highest level of restriction.
A total of 142 patients were included. During NOAC treatment, minor bleeds were reported by 87 patients (61%) of whom 16 (11%) suffered from a CRNMB. All patients that suffered from a CRNMB contacted their treating physician and 13 received treatment. The most frequently reported CRNMBs were epistaxis ( = 6), a bleed after injury ( = 3), rectal bleed ( = 2) and an eye bleed ( = 2). With regard to the impact of a CRNMB, the median level of annoyance was 8 (min-max 2-10)) and the level of concern 4 (min-max 1-10). The MARS-5 score for adherence to treatment was only marginally influenced. Also the level of trust remained high after the CRNMB. Out of 12 patients, only 2 patients reported a reduction of 1 and 8 points, respectively. Ten patients scored no change and one patient scored a 1 point increase in the level of trust. The mean reduction in trust was 0.7 (95%CI -0.8 to 2.2). With regard to the reported restrictions on physical activities, 8 out of 12 patients reported no (score 1) or only marginal impact (score 2), 2 patients reported a moderate impact (score 5 and 6) and 2 patients reported a high impact score 7 (mean score 2.9 (95%CI 1.3-4.5). For the daily life impact question, 5 out of 9 patients reported no or only marginal impact, 3 patients reported a moderate impact (scores 4 and 5) and 1 patient reported maximal impact (score 10) (mean score 3.2 (95%CI 0.9-5.5)).
In our study the level of trust, annoyance and concern were not significantly impacted by the CRNMB, nor the adherence to treatment and impact on daily life and physical activities. However, on an individual basis, there were patients that reported a high impact. We hope that future data on impact of this type of minor bleeds will help us identify and guide suboptimaly adherent NOAC patients in shared decision manner.
在先前一项关于房颤患者停用新型口服抗凝治疗(NOAC)原因的研究中,我们发现轻微出血是停用NOAC的第二大重要原因。这一发现表明,轻微出血对患者对NOAC的看法的影响不容忽视,尤其是那些患者为此寻求医疗护理的轻微出血。因此,我们开展了一项研究,探讨轻微出血(临床相关非大出血)对使用NOAC的房颤患者的治疗信心、治疗依从性和生活质量的影响。
使用半结构化电话访谈评估NOAC治疗的详细情况、信心水平、依从性和生活质量。与烦恼、担忧和信任相关的问题按1至10分进行评分,10分代表最高影响水平或信任度。对于轻微出血前后的治疗依从性,使用药物依从性评定量表(MARS-5)问卷。MARS-5总分范围为5至25分;5分表示依从性差,25分表示完全依从。此外,使用1至10分的视觉模拟评分(VAS)评估出血对身体活动和日常生活的影响;10分代表最高限制水平。
共纳入142例患者。在NOAC治疗期间,87例患者(61%)报告有轻微出血,其中16例(11%)发生临床相关非大出血(CRNMB)。所有发生CRNMB的患者均联系了他们的主治医生,13例接受了治疗。最常报告的CRNMB为鼻出血(n = 6)、受伤后出血(n = 3)、直肠出血(n = 2)和眼部出血(n = 2)。关于CRNMB的影响,烦恼的中位数水平为8(最小值 - 最大值2 - 10),担忧水平为4(最小值 - 最大值1 - 10)。治疗依从性的MARS-5评分仅受到轻微影响。CRNMB后信任水平也保持较高。在12例患者中,只有2例患者分别报告信任度降低了1分和8分。10例患者评分无变化,1例患者信任度增加了1分。信任度的平均降低为0.7(95%CI -0.8至2.2)。关于报告的对身体活动的限制,12例患者中有8例报告无(评分为1)或仅有轻微影响(评分为2),2例患者报告有中度影响(评分为5和6),2例患者报告有高度影响(评分为7)(平均评分2.9(95%CI 1.3 - 4.5))。对于日常生活影响问题,9例患者中有5例报告无或仅有轻微影响,3例患者报告有中度影响(评分为4和5),1例患者报告有最大影响(评分为10)(平均评分3.2(95%CI 0.9 - 5.5))。
在我们的研究中,CRNMB对信任、烦恼和担忧水平、治疗依从性以及对日常生活和身体活动的影响均无显著影响。然而,在个体层面上,有患者报告影响较大。我们希望未来关于这类轻微出血影响的数据将有助于我们以共同决策的方式识别和指导NOAC治疗依从性欠佳的患者。