Northumbria Healthcare NHS FoundationTrust, North Shields, England, UK.
Clin Rheumatol. 2022 Sep;41(9):2695-2700. doi: 10.1007/s10067-022-06232-w. Epub 2022 Jun 7.
The cost-effectiveness of higher cost drugs (HCDs) after several failures is disputed by some purchasers of services for people with rheumatoid arthritis (RA). We were interested to explore our service experience of using HCDs beyond the third choice to document response rates and duration of treatments.
Records from our multi-disciplinary team meeting (MDT) that is used to decide on the use of HCDs were used to identify all RA patients who had been exposed to four or more HCDs. Notes were scrutinised for sequence of treatments, duration and response to treatments and reasons for stopping at each choice point.
From a total of 2648 RA patients in our service, 49 (< 2%) had been exposed to four or more HCDs. Response rates based on descriptive assessments for fourth to sixth choices were between 50 and 55% as well as some partial responders. There were responders and failures to all drugs at every choice point. Patients who had responded to one drug were more likely to respond to the next. Patients often responded to drugs for approximately 2 years. Only four patients had stopped looking for the next HCD.
Patients often respond to late choice HCDs. There are responders and failures at each time point and they are difficult to predict. There is no justification for restricting the number of HCDs that can be tried for RA. Key Points • Less than 2% of our RA patients required 4 or more higher cost drugs. • Fourth to sixth choice drugs still worked in 50 to 55% of patients. • There is no justification for CCGs restricting the number of drugs that can be tried.
一些为类风湿关节炎(RA)患者提供服务的服务购买者对多次失败后高成本药物(HCD)的成本效益存在争议。我们有兴趣探索我们使用 HCD 的经验,超越了第三个选择,以记录反应率和治疗持续时间。
我们的多学科团队会议(MDT)记录用于决定使用 HCD,用于确定所有已经接触过四种或更多种 HCD 的 RA 患者。仔细审查笔记以了解治疗顺序、治疗持续时间和反应以及在每个选择点停止的原因。
在我们的服务中,共有 2648 名 RA 患者,有 49 名(<2%)接触过四种或更多种 HCD。第四至第六种选择的基于描述性评估的反应率在 50%至 55%之间,也有一些部分反应者。在每个选择点都有对所有药物的反应者和失败。对一种药物有反应的患者更有可能对下一种药物有反应。患者通常对药物有反应约 2 年。只有四名患者停止寻找下一种 HCD。
患者通常对晚期选择的 HCD 有反应。每个时间点都有反应者和失败,而且很难预测。没有理由限制可以尝试治疗 RA 的 HCD 数量。要点:不到 2%的 RA 患者需要 4 种或更多种更高成本的药物。第四至第六种选择的药物在 50%至 55%的患者中仍然有效。CCG 没有理由限制可以尝试的药物数量。