Holmberg S, Kalén R, Thorngren K G
Clin Orthop Relat Res. 1987 May(218):42-52.
All patients admitted from their own homes with a femoral neck fracture to 12 hospitals in Stockholm County Council during a three-year period were reviewed six years after the fracture. The outcome of the fractures was related to different types of treatment centers (orthopedic and surgical) and primary treatments (conservative, internal fixation, and hemiarthroplasty [HAP]). The treatment results of the four most common types of internal fixation (von Bahr, Hessel/Nyström, Thornton, and Rydell nails), the experience of the surgeons, and the operative delay were also compared. Of 2418 patients, the majority (93%) were treated with internal fixation. Thirty-three percent of patients sustained complications after conservative treatment, 37% after primary internal fixation, and 15% after primary HAP. Early redisplacement of the fracture was most common when the Thornton nail was used and when less experienced surgeons treated the fractures. Early complications such as redisplacement and nonunion occurred most often in surgical departments, but the total frequency of complications including segmental collapse was equal for different treatment centers. In surgical departments these fractures were operatively treated most often by less experienced surgeons and the Thornton nail was used more frequently than in orthopedic departments. An operative delay of up to one week did not result in more complications. Seventy percent of the complications after primary treatment were reoperated. Only 11% were not reoperated, either because of the presence of only minor symptoms, or because of the patient's poor general condition, which made reoperation too risky. The results of the present study stress the importance of stable fixation of this fracture and of the experience of the surgeon for optimal treatment results.
对斯德哥尔摩郡议会下属12家医院在三年期间收治的所有从家中入院的股骨颈骨折患者,在骨折六年之后进行了复查。骨折的治疗结果与不同类型的治疗中心(骨科和外科)以及初始治疗方法(保守治疗、内固定和半髋关节置换术[HAP])相关。还比较了四种最常见的内固定类型(冯·巴尔、赫塞尔/奈斯特伦、桑顿和吕德尔钉)的治疗结果、外科医生的经验以及手术延迟情况。在2418例患者中,大多数(93%)接受了内固定治疗。保守治疗后33%的患者出现并发症,初次内固定后为37%,初次HAP后为15%。使用桑顿钉以及经验较少的外科医生治疗骨折时,骨折早期再移位最为常见。早期并发症如再移位和骨不连最常发生在外科科室,但不同治疗中心包括节段性塌陷在内的并发症总发生率相同。在外科科室,这些骨折大多由经验较少的外科医生进行手术治疗,且桑顿钉的使用频率高于骨科科室。手术延迟长达一周并未导致更多并发症。初次治疗后70%的并发症患者接受了再次手术。只有11%的患者未进行再次手术,要么是因为仅存在轻微症状,要么是因为患者全身状况较差,再次手术风险太大。本研究结果强调了稳定固定该骨折以及外科医生经验对于获得最佳治疗效果的重要性。