Physician and Rheumatologist, Hawke's Bay District Health Board, Hastings.
Department of Medicine, University of Otago Wellington, Wellington; Rheumatologist, Hutt Valley District Health Board.
N Z Med J. 2022 Apr 1;135:27-36.
To identify consensus of rheumatologists on components of best practice rheumatology service in district health boards (DHB) in Aotearoa New Zealand (AoNZ).
A consensus survey of rheumatologists in AoNZ was informed by an initial survey inviting modifications to statements about best practice rheumatology from international literature and requested additional statements. The three-round consensus email exercise asked rheumatologists to indicate their level of agreement with each statement for a DHB serving a small or large population. Consensus for each statement was achieved when ≥80% of participants' votes were within a pre-determined category (essential, potentially desirable, to be avoided).
Ten rheumatologists reviewed the 19 initial statements with three additional statements offered-the consensus survey had 22 statements. Twenty-six rheumatologists responded in the first consensus round, with 21/26 (81%) responding in rounds two and three. After three rounds, 16 statements met consensus as essential for both small and large DHB rheumatology services. One statement met consensus as potentially desirable for a large rheumatology service. Five statements did not reach consensus.
The component statements identified by consensus can inform policy and implementation of rheumatology services in the AoNZ health system reforms and be used for benchmarking.
确定新西兰奥塔哥(AoNZ)地区卫生委员会(DHB)中风湿病专家对最佳实践风湿病服务组成部分的共识。
通过对 AoNZ 风湿病专家的共识调查,对来自国际文献的最佳实践风湿病的陈述进行了初步调查,邀请他们对这些陈述进行修改,并要求提出其他陈述。三轮共识电子邮件调查要求风湿病专家就每一项服务于小或大人群的 DHB 的陈述表明其同意程度。当≥80%的参与者投票属于预定类别(必要的、潜在可取的、应避免的)时,该陈述即达成共识。
10 名风湿病专家审查了 19 项初始陈述,并提供了另外 3 项陈述——共识调查有 22 项陈述。26 名风湿病专家在第一轮共识中做出了回应,其中 21/26(81%)在第二轮和第三轮中做出了回应。三轮过后,16 项陈述对小和大 DHB 风湿病服务均被认为是必不可少的。一项陈述对大型风湿病服务被认为是可取的。五项陈述未达成共识。
通过共识确定的组成部分陈述可以为 AoNZ 卫生系统改革中的风湿病服务的政策制定和实施提供信息,并可用于基准测试。