Comparative evaluation of the Geenius HCV supplemental assay and Inno-LIA HCV score assay in detecting anti-HCV antibodies.

OBJECTIVE

This study compared two assays aimed at confirming the presence of anti-HCV antibodies (Ab) after a positive screening: Geenius HCV supplemental assay (Bio-Rad, Marne la Coquette, France) and the Inno-LIA HCV score assay (Fujirebio, Les Ulis, France).

MATERIAL AND METHODS

A total of 180 archived samples were investigated including 119 samples collected at different stages of HCV infection in 25 hemodialyzed patients who underwent HCV seroconversion, 14 samples from 4 commercial seroconversion panels, 47 Ab positive/HCV-RNA positive blood donations of which 7 showing an single reactivity in confirmatory assays. Samples were investigated and results were interpreted with the two assays according to the manufacturers' instructions.

RESULTS

Overall, Geenius and Inno-LIA were concordant for 84% (151/180) samples: 38 negative, 17 indeterminate and 96 positive. Of the 29 discrepant results, 26 were overclassified with Inno-LIA. HCV seroconversion was detected with Inno-LIA 4 and 7 days prior to Geenius in two panels. The high positive rate observed with Inno-LIA (64%) compared to Geenius (54%) was mainly due to low reactivities considered positive according to interpretation criteria, which could affect specificity.

CONCLUSION

Although HCV supplemental assays are not recommended for the diagnostic of HCV infection, which is primarily based on HCV-RNA testing, both assays are suitable as second line anti-HCV tests when Ab screening is positive and RNA testing cannot be performed. Moreover, Geenius system provides an objective result in less than 30minutes, which is compatible when a rapid diagnostic is required.