Department of Primary Dental Care, Division of Dental Hygiene, University of Minnesota School of Dentistry, Minneapolis, Minnesota, USA.
University of Michigan School of Dentistry, Ann Arbor, Michigan, USA.
J Dent Educ. 2022 Nov;86(11):1448-1458. doi: 10.1002/jdd.13009. Epub 2022 Jun 23.
The purpose of this study was to elicit ideas or concerns influencing dental hygiene educators' experiences of personal and professional burnout, burnout working with students, and teaching efficacy in an online/hybrid environment as a result of the COVID-19 pandemic.
A qualitative, content-analysis study included a convenience sample of dental hygiene educators emails. An invitation to participate in an August 2021 or October 2021 focus group was sent via Qualtrics with informed consent, and focus groups were held over Zoom. Conversations were audio recorded, transcribed, and de-identified. Consensus on a codebook by two coders achieved an 88% agreement.
Fifty-three were invited to the August 2021 focus groups for a 26% (n = 14) response rate, and 116 were invited to the October 2021 focus groups for an 11% (n = 13) response rate. Contributing factors to experiences of burnout expressed were: (1) work-life balance (n = 59), including (a) overwork, (b) pressure to be available, and (c) lack of boundaries; (2) change (n = 34) involving (a) developing new protocols, (b) constant uncertainty, (c) COVID-19 requirements, and (d) new platforms; and (3) negative interactions (n = 32) with (a) students and (b) faculty.
A lack of work-life balance from overwork, pressure to be available at all times, no boundaries with students, and an absence of a sense of connection for workplace vitality were contributors to burnout. Work-from-home flexibility, a work environment that supported wellness and mental well-being, and the ability to leave the workplace for periods of time were reported as helpful solutions to combatting burnout.
本研究旨在征集因 COVID-19 大流行而在在线/混合环境中对牙科卫生教育者的个人和职业倦怠、与学生一起工作倦怠以及教学效能产生影响的想法或关注点。
一项定性内容分析研究包括牙科卫生教育者电子邮件的方便样本。通过 Qualtrics 发送了参加 2021 年 8 月或 2021 年 10 月焦点小组的邀请,附上了知情同意书,并通过 Zoom 举行了焦点小组会议。对话被录音、转录并进行了身份识别。两名编目员对编目手册达成了 88%的一致意见。
邀请了 53 人参加 2021 年 8 月的焦点小组,回复率为 26%(n=14),邀请了 116 人参加 2021 年 10 月的焦点小组,回复率为 11%(n=13)。表达的倦怠经历的促成因素包括:(1)工作与生活的平衡(n=59),包括(a)过度工作,(b)随时待命的压力,以及(c)缺乏界限;(2)变化(n=34)涉及(a)制定新协议,(b)持续的不确定性,(c)COVID-19 要求,以及(d)新平台;(3)与(a)学生和(b)教师的负面互动(n=32)。
由于过度工作、随时待命的压力、与学生没有界限以及工作场所活力缺乏联系,导致工作与生活的平衡失调,是倦怠的促成因素。在家工作的灵活性、支持身心健康的工作环境以及离开工作场所一段时间的能力,被报道为应对倦怠的有益解决方案。