Division of Neonatal-Perinatal Medicine, The Department of Pediatrics, The University of Oklahoma Health Sciences Center, Oklahoma City, OK, USA.
Division of Neonatal-Perinatal Medicine, The Department of Pediatrics, The University of Texas Southwestern Medical Center/Children's Medical Center, Dallas, TX, USA.
J Telemed Telecare. 2024 Jun;30(5):895-902. doi: 10.1177/1357633X221104563. Epub 2022 Jun 28.
Managing critically ill neonates has unique challenges, and the transport team plays an important role in stabilizing and facilitating the transfer of these neonates from lower-level nurseries to tertiary centers, and the use of telemedicine in transport (tele-transport) can potentially benefit patient care. We conducted a multicenter study to assess the readiness for utilizing telemedicine as an adjunct to guide the care of critically ill neonates among physicians and transport team members (TTMs). This is the first multicenter study that explored physicians' and TTMs' perceptions of telemedicine usage and its value in neonatal transport.
A confidential, voluntary survey on pre-implementation attitudes toward telemedicine usage during neonatal transport was conducted as part of a quality improvement initiative. This survey involved physicians and TTMs from four academic institutions whose responses were entered into an online survey using REDCap®. The survey inquired about satisfaction with the current practice of phone consultation and the perception of using telemedicine to optimize the management of neonates during transport.
The overall response rate for the survey was 60.1%; 82 of 127 (64.6%) physicians and 64 of 116 (55.2%) TTMs responded to the surveys. Half of the physicians and less than one-fourth of the TTMs had prior experience with telemedicine other than that used on neonatal transport. TTMs expressed greater concern about the inconvenience of video (55% vs. physicians 35% or ) and its time consumption (84% vs. physicians 50%). More than 70% of physicians and less than half of TTMs endorsed the potential for added value and quality improvement with video capability. Almost half of TTMs reported concern about video calls reducing their autonomy in patient care. Physicians expressed confidence in management decisions they would make after video calls (72% or ) and less confidence (49%) about both the phone assessment by TTMs and their decisions based on phone assessment. In contrast, TTMs were confident or very confident (94%) in both sharing their assessment over the phone and executing patient management after a phone call, compared with 70% for decisions made after video calls.
Physicians and TTMs had distinct opinions on the use of telemedicine during neonatal transport. Physicians were more likely than TTMs to agree with statements about the potential for improving quality of care, while TTMs were more likely than physicians to say video calls would be time-consuming and inconvenient. We speculate some differences may stem from the TTMs' concern about losing their autonomy. Therefore, during implementation, it is critical for physicians and TTMs to agree on a shared mental model of indications for telemedicine during transport and its value to the patient care.
危重新生儿的管理具有独特的挑战,转运团队在稳定和促进这些新生儿从低级别护理病房向三级中心转移方面发挥着重要作用,而在转运过程中使用远程医疗(远程转运)可能对患者护理有益。我们进行了一项多中心研究,以评估医师和转运团队成员(TTM)在使用远程医疗作为指导危重新生儿护理的辅助手段方面的准备情况。这是第一项探索医师和 TTM 对远程医疗使用的看法及其在新生儿转运中的价值的多中心研究。
作为质量改进计划的一部分,我们进行了一项关于在新生儿转运过程中使用远程医疗的预实施态度的机密、自愿调查。这项调查涉及来自四个学术机构的医师和 TTM,他们的回答通过 REDCap®输入在线调查。该调查询问了他们对当前电话咨询实践的满意度以及使用远程医疗优化转运中新生儿管理的看法。
该调查的总体回复率为 60.1%;127 名医师中有 82 名(64.6%)和 116 名 TTM 中有 64 名(55.2%)回复了调查。一半的医师和不到四分之一的 TTM 有除新生儿转运之外的远程医疗经验。TTM 对视频的不便(55%比医师 35%)和耗时(84%比医师 50%)表示更多担忧。超过 70%的医师和不到一半的 TTM 认可视频功能的附加价值和质量改进。近一半的 TTM 担心视频通话会降低他们在患者护理方面的自主权。医师对视频通话后做出的管理决策有信心(72%),但对 TTM 电话评估及其基于电话评估做出的决策的信心较低(49%)。相比之下,TTM 对电话评估结果和电话后执行的患者管理充满信心(94%)或非常有信心,而对视频通话后做出的决策有信心的比例为 70%。
医师和 TTM 对新生儿转运过程中使用远程医疗有不同的看法。医师比 TTM 更有可能同意改善护理质量的可能性的说法,而 TTM 比医师更有可能表示视频通话会很耗时和不便。我们推测,一些差异可能源于 TTM 对失去自主权的担忧。因此,在实施过程中,医师和 TTM 必须就转运过程中使用远程医疗的适应症及其对患者护理的价值达成共同的心理模型。