College of Chemical Engineering, State Key Laboratory of Materials-Oriented Chemical Engineering, Nanjing, China.
Zhangjiagang Institute of Nanjing Tech University, Zhangjiagang, China.
J Comput Chem. 2022 Sep 15;43(24):1621-1632. doi: 10.1002/jcc.26963. Epub 2022 Jul 8.
The ion association is widely believed to be dominated by the favorable entropy change arising from the release of water molecules from ion hydration shells. However, no direct thermodynamic evidence exists to validate the reliability and suitability of this view. Herein, we employ complicated free energy calculations to rigorously split the free energy including its entropic and enthalpic components into the water-induced contributions and ion-ion interaction terms for several ion pairs from monatomic to polyatomic ions, spanning the size range from small kosmotropes to large chaotropes (Na , Cs , Ca , F , I , CO , and HPO ). Our results successfully reveal that though ion associations are indeed determined by a delicate balance between the favorable entropy variation and the repulsive enthalpy change, the entropy gain dominated by the solvent occurs only for the monatomic ion pairing. The water-induced entropic contribution significantly goes against the ion pairing between polyatomic anion and cation, which is, alternatively, dominated by the favorable entropy from the ion-ion interaction term, due to the configurational arrangement of polyatomic anions involved in ion association. The structural and dynamic analysis demonstrates that the entropy penalty from the water phase is primarily ascribed to the enhanced stability of water molecules around the cation imposed by the incoming anion. Our study successfully provides a fundamental understanding of water-mediated ion associations and highlights disparate lengthscale dependencies of the dehydration thermodynamics on the specific types of ions.
离子缔合被广泛认为主要是由于水合离子外壳中水分子的释放导致的有利熵变。然而,目前尚无直接的热力学证据来验证这种观点的可靠性和适用性。在此,我们采用复杂的自由能计算方法,严格地将自由能(包括其熵和焓分量)分解为水诱导贡献和离子-离子相互作用项,用于从单原子离子到多原子离子的几个离子对,跨越从小的亲水分子到大的疏水分子(Na+、Cs+、Ca2+、F-、I-、CO32- 和 HPO42-)的尺寸范围。我们的结果成功地揭示了尽管离子缔合确实是由有利的熵变和排斥焓变之间的微妙平衡决定的,但溶剂引起的熵增益仅适用于单原子离子对。水诱导的熵贡献显著不利于多原子阴离子和阳离子之间的离子对,相反,由于涉及离子缔合的多原子阴离子的构型排列,离子-离子相互作用项的有利熵主导了这种离子对。结构和动力学分析表明,来自水相的熵罚主要归因于阴离子进入时阳离子周围水分子稳定性的增强。我们的研究成功地提供了对水介导的离子缔合的基本理解,并强调了脱水热力学对特定类型离子的不同长度尺度依赖性。