Vázquez-Mosquera Juan M, de Mercado Eduardo, Fernández-Novo Aitor, Gardón Juan C, Pesántez-Pacheco José L, Pérez-Solana María Luz, Revilla-Ruiz Ángel, Martínez Daniel, Villagrá Arantxa, Sebastián Francisco, Pérez-Garnelo Sonia S, Astiz Susana
Medicine and Surgery Department, Veterinary Faculty, Complutense University of Madrid, Puerta de Hierro Avenue s/n, 28040 Madrid, Spain.
Animal Reproduction Department, National Institute of Agronomic Research (INIA-CSIC), Puerta de Hierro Avenue s/n, 28040 Madrid, Spain.
Animals (Basel). 2022 Jun 29;12(13):1671. doi: 10.3390/ani12131671.
Japanese Black (Wagyu) cattle produce high-quality beef. However, whether Wagyu steers can be profitably raised under conditions different than the traditional Japanese ones remains unclear. From 2018 to 2020, we raised 262 Wagyu purebred steers, 103 Wagyu-by-Angus (Wangus) crossbred steers, and 43 Angus-by-European (ACL) crossbred steers on a Spanish farm with high welfare standards and a locally sourced, high-olein diet. Factors and factors' interactions impacting steer growth were analyzed using generalized linear models. ACL steers grew faster than the other two groups, with Wangus showing intermediate fattening and muscle development. Average daily weight gains (kg/day) were 0.916 for Wagyu, 1.046 for Wangus, and 1.293 for ACL during the weaning to growing period, and 0.628 for Wagyu, 0.64 for Wangus, and 0.802 for ACL during the growing to fattening phase. ACL showed the lowest marbling rates. Wagyu and Wangus usually showed higher cholesterol, triglycerides, and high-density lipoprotein than ACL. ACL calves may experience greater stress at weaning, as suggested by higher glucose, lactate, and β-hydroxybutyrate than the other groups. The results suggest that Wagyu and Wangus steers showed adequate growth, health, and metabolic development in this type of production system, with Wagyu purebreds probably being more profitable than Wangus crossbreeds.
日本黑毛(和牛)牛产出高品质牛肉。然而,和牛阉牛在不同于传统日本养殖条件下能否盈利养殖仍不明确。2018年至2020年,我们在西班牙一个具有高福利标准且采用当地采购的高油酸日粮的农场饲养了262头和牛纯种阉牛、103头和牛与安格斯牛的杂交(王牛)阉牛以及43头安格斯牛与欧洲牛的杂交(ACL)阉牛。使用广义线性模型分析了影响阉牛生长的因素及其相互作用。ACL阉牛生长速度比其他两组更快,王牛在育肥和肌肉发育方面表现居中。在断奶至生长阶段,和牛的平均日增重(千克/天)为0.916,王牛为1.046,ACL为1.293;在生长至育肥阶段,和牛为0.628,王牛为0.64,ACL为0.802。ACL的大理石花纹率最低。和牛与王牛的胆固醇、甘油三酯和高密度脂蛋白通常高于ACL。ACL犊牛在断奶时可能经历更大压力,这表现为其葡萄糖、乳酸和β-羟基丁酸水平高于其他组。结果表明,在这种生产系统中,和牛与王牛阉牛生长、健康及代谢发育良好,和牛纯种可能比王牛杂交种更具盈利性。