Stastna Daniela, Mannion Richard, Axon Patrick, Moffat David Andrew, Donnelly Neil, Tysome James R, Hardy David G, Bance Mahonar, Joannides Alexis, Lawes Indu, Macfarlane Robert
Department of Neurosurgery, Addenbrooke's Hospital, Cambridge University Hospitals, Cambridge, United Kingdom.
Department of ENT, Addenbrooke's Hospital, Cambridge University Hospitals, Cambridge, United Kingdom.
J Neurol Surg B Skull Base. 2021 Mar 1;83(Suppl 2):e216-e224. doi: 10.1055/s-0041-1725028. eCollection 2022 Jun.
Cystic vestibular schwannomas (VS) in contrast to solid VS tend to have accelerated growth, larger volume, rapid/atypical presentation, lobulated/adherent surface, and unpredictable course of the cranial nerves. Cystic VS are surgically challenging, with worse clinical outcomes and higher rate of subtotal resection (STR). We retrospectively analyzed postoperative outcomes of 125 patients with cystic VS, operated between years 2005 and 2019 in our center. We confronted the extent of the resection and House-Brackmann (HB) grade of facial palsy with the results of comparable cohort of patients with solid VS operated in our center and literature review by Thakur et al. Translabyrinthine approach was preferred for resection of large, cystic VS (97.6%). Gross-total resection (GTR) was achieved in 78 patients (62.4%), near-total resection (NTR) with remnant (<4 × 4 × 2 mm) in 43 patients (34.4%), and STR in 4 patients (3.2%). NTR/STR were significantly associated with higher age, tumor volume >5 cm , retrosigmoid approach, high-riding jugular bulb, tumor adherence to the brain stem, and facial nerve ( = 0.016; 0.003; 0.005; 0.025; 0.001; and <0.00001, respectively). One year after the surgery, 76% of patients had HB grades 1 to 2, 16% had HB grades 3 to 4, and 8% had HB grades 5 to 6 palsy. Worse outcome (HB grades 3 to 6) was associated with preoperative facial palsy, tumor volume >25 cm , and cyst over the brain stem ( = 0.045; 0.014; and 0.05, respectively). Comparable solid VS operated in our center had significantly higher HB grades 1 to 2 rate than our cystic VS (94% versus 76%; = 0.03). Comparing our results with literature review, our HB grades 1 to 2 rate was significantly higher (76% versus 39%; = 0.0001). Tumor control rate 5 years after surgery was 95.8%. Our study confirmed that microsurgery of cystic VS has worse outcomes of facial nerve preservation and extent of resection compared with solid VS. Greater attention should be paid to the above-mentioned risk factors.
与实性前庭神经鞘瘤(VS)相比,囊性VS往往生长加速、体积更大、表现迅速/不典型、表面呈分叶状/粘连,且颅神经走行不可预测。囊性VS的手术具有挑战性,临床结果较差,次全切除(STR)率较高。我们回顾性分析了2005年至2019年在我们中心接受手术的125例囊性VS患者的术后结果。我们将切除范围和面部神经麻痹的House-Brackmann(HB)分级与我们中心接受手术的实性VS患者的可比队列结果以及Thakur等人的文献综述进行了对比。经迷路入路是切除大型囊性VS的首选方法(97.6%)。78例患者(62.4%)实现了全切除(GTR),43例患者(34.4%)实现了近全切除(NTR),残留灶(<4×4×2mm),4例患者(3.2%)为STR。NTR/STR与较高年龄、肿瘤体积>5cm³、乙状窦后入路、高位颈静脉球、肿瘤与脑干和面神经粘连显著相关(分别为P = 0.016;0.003;0.005;0.025;0.001;<0.00001)。术后1年,76%的患者HB分级为1至2级,16%的患者HB分级为3至4级,8%的患者HB分级为5至6级麻痹。较差的结果(HB分级3至6级)与术前面部神经麻痹、肿瘤体积>25cm³和脑干上方囊肿有关(分别为P = 0.045;0.014;0.05)。我们中心接受手术的可比实性VS的HB分级1至2级率明显高于我们的囊性VS(94%对76%;P = 0.03)。将我们的结果与文献综述进行比较,我们的HB分级1至2级率明显更高(76%对39%;P = 0.0001)。术后5年的肿瘤控制率为95.8%。我们的研究证实,与实性VS相比,囊性VS的显微手术在面神经保留和切除范围方面的结果更差。应更加关注上述危险因素。