Tew M, Forster I W
J Bone Joint Surg Br. 1987 May;69(3):395-9. doi: 10.1302/0301-620X.69B3.3584192.
One of the objectives of knee replacement is to correct flexion deformity, the frequent consequence of rheumatoid arthritis and osteoarthritis. A review of 697 primary and revision replacements carried out between 1969 and 1985 and followed up from 1 to 16 years found that such deformity was present in 61% of knees before the primary operation. Replacement reduced this to 17% and the improvement was usually maintained. The deformity was present in only 21% of the replacements which required revision and the second operation reduced this to 8%. Flexion contractures affected rheumatoid knees more often and more seriously than osteoarthritic knees, but arthroplasty was more successful in correcting the deformity in the former. All of the 11 types of prosthesis used achieved some degree of correction, but the Walldius hinge and the variants of the Freeman condylar design were the most successful. Surprisingly, the best outcome, in terms of pain and reduced need for revision, was found in the rheumatoid knees most seriously deformed before operation, but this association was absent in the osteoarthritic knees. Postoperative deformity in knees without pain or extreme weakness did not appear to influence the patients' ability to walk or to use stairs or a chair, as measured by unexacting tests in the clinic.
膝关节置换的目标之一是纠正屈曲畸形,这是类风湿性关节炎和骨关节炎常见的后果。回顾1969年至1985年间进行的697例初次置换和翻修置换手术,并对患者进行1至16年的随访,发现初次手术前61%的膝关节存在这种畸形。置换术后该比例降至17%,且改善情况通常得以维持。在需要翻修的置换手术中,仅有21%的膝关节存在畸形,二次手术后该比例降至8%。与骨关节炎膝关节相比,屈曲挛缩在类风湿性膝关节中更常见且更严重,但关节成形术在纠正前者的畸形方面更成功。所使用的11种植入物均实现了一定程度的矫正,但瓦尔迪厄斯铰链式和弗里曼髁型设计的变体最为成功。令人惊讶的是,就疼痛和减少翻修需求而言,最佳结果出现在术前畸形最严重的类风湿性膝关节中,但骨关节炎膝关节中不存在这种关联。根据诊所中不太严格的测试,无疼痛或极度虚弱的膝关节术后畸形似乎并未影响患者行走、上下楼梯或使用椅子的能力。