Emergency Medicine, San Giovanni Bosco Hospital, Turin, Italy.
Department of Letters, Philosophy and Communication, University of Bergamo, Bergamo, Italy.
Intern Emerg Med. 2022 Oct;17(7):1899-1905. doi: 10.1007/s11739-022-03024-7. Epub 2022 Jul 19.
Hand hygiene among professionals plays a crucial role in preventing healthcare-associated infections, yet poor compliance in hospital settings remains a lasting reason for concern. Nudge theory is an innovative approach to behavioral change first developed in economics and cognitive psychology, and recently spread and discussed in clinical medicine. To assess a combined nudge intervention (localized dispensers, visual reminders, and gain-framed posters) to promote hand hygiene compliance among hospital personnel. A quasi-experimental study including a pre-intervention phase and a post-intervention phase (9 + 9 consecutive months) with 117 professionals overall from three wards in a 350-bed general city hospital. Hand hygiene compliance was measured using direct observations by trained personnel and measurement of alcohol-based hand-rub consumption. Levels of hand hygiene compliance were low in the pre-intervention phase: 11.44% of hand hygiene opportunities prescribed were fulfilled overall. We observed a statistically significant effect of the nudge intervention with an increase to 18.71% (p < 0.001) in the post-intervention phase. Improvement was observed in all experimental settings (the three hospital wards). A statistical comparison across three subsequent periods of the post-intervention phase revealed no significant decay of the effect. An assessment of the collected data on alcohol-based hand-rub consumption indirectly confirms the main result in all experimental settings. Behavioral outcomes concerning hand hygiene in the hospital are indeed affected by contextual, nudging factors to a significant extent. If properly devised, nudging measures can provide a sustainable contribution to increase hand hygiene compliance in a hospital setting.
专业人员的手部卫生对于预防医源性感染至关重要,但医院环境中依从性差仍然是一个持久的问题。推动理论是一种创新的行为改变方法,最初在经济学和认知心理学中发展起来,最近在临床医学中得到了推广和讨论。评估一种综合的推动干预措施(本地化分配器、视觉提示和增益框架海报),以提高医院人员的手部卫生依从性。一项准实验研究包括干预前阶段和干预后阶段(共 9+9 个连续月),共有来自一家 350 张床位的城市综合医院三个病房的 117 名专业人员参与。通过训练有素的人员进行直接观察和测量酒精基手部擦拭消耗量来衡量手部卫生依从性。干预前阶段手部卫生依从性水平较低:总体规定的手部卫生机会中只有 11.44%得到了满足。我们观察到推动干预的统计学显著效果,干预后阶段手部卫生依从性增加到 18.71%(p<0.001)。在所有实验环境中都观察到了改善。在干预后阶段的三个后续时期进行的统计学比较显示,效果没有明显衰减。对收集的酒精基手部擦拭消耗量数据的评估在所有实验环境中间接证实了主要结果。医院内手部卫生的行为结果确实在很大程度上受到环境、推动因素的影响。如果设计得当,推动措施可以为提高医院环境中的手部卫生依从性做出可持续的贡献。